MovieChat Forums > Shop Talk Writers > How much does legal accuracy matter in a...

How much does legal accuracy matter in a thriller to audiences?


For a script I was writing, which is of the serious thriller genre, I did some legal research by talking to a lawyer, and coming up with legally accurate scenarios for my story to unfold in to keep it real.

Later I asked another lawyer to go over it, and he said that it's not legally accurate at all, and that the lawyer I talked to must be very inexperienced. But I don't think I could rewrite the third act in a legally accurate way, without it leading to plot holes.

So I was wondering, how much to audiences care about realism, in a thriller that is set in the police and court world?

Some movies make things up I found out by doing my own research, but it's hard to know where the line is drawn.

reply

I think it matters a lot whether your plot and characters follow legal conventions in arrests, the rights of the accused, and the courtroom procedure. It's not like there's hardly anyone who will notice an overt mistake; lawyers are plentiful and most go to the movies. Thanks to most TV shows and movies making an effort to reflect reality in US legal proceedings, there are also lots of non-lawyers who know a lot about the law and will recognize the instant your fictional cop gives the accused a basis for a mistrial or the dropping of all charges, or a courtroom stunt which would land the attorney in jail and get him kicked out of the bar association, no longer able to practice.

You might get away with a goof in some more esoteric profession, but in law? I'd guess you might slip a small mistake which does not affect the outcome past your audience, but only one.

Speed
Want to know what people are most terrified of? Look at how they insult others. It's that.

reply

STRONGLY AGREE

reply

Depends on who your audience is. Grisham audiences will be less forgiving of mistakes than My Cousin Vinny or The Devil's Advocate's audience. In "a thriller that is set in the police and court world", as you say, I suspect that accuracy will be very important to your audience.

Out of curiosity, are you just going to reframe the same question every few weeks until somebody gives you the answer you want?

reply

Grisham audiences will be less forgiving of mistakes than My Cousin Vinny or The Devil's Advocate's audience.
Would you believe my Evidence Prof. made us watch My Cousin Vinny in class?

He was... an interesting character lol.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

It's been years since I watched it, long before I started working in a legal profession. Is there a lesson about trial law and evidence somewhere in the movie?

reply

IIRC, he was particularly enamored of Vinny's opening statement, because it was purely negative ("Everything that guy said is BS.") and thus didn't pin down the defense to any one theory or position. I think he also thought Vinny's impeachment of the witnesses for the prosecution was effective.

As I say, however, this guy was kind of a character. My suspicion is he just wanted us to watch a movie in class lol.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

Grisham audiences will be less forgiving of mistakes than My Cousin Vinny['s audience]

Well this is wrong... apparently...

There's the ABA Journal. That's the "American Bar Association Journal"

From Wikipedia.

The ABA Journal is a monthly legal trade magazine and the flagship publication of the American Bar Association.

On their website:

http://www.abajournal.com/gallery/top25movies/89

Yep, that's right, number 3! Behind "To Kill a Mockingbird" and "12 Angry Men!"


They even say it has their:

best-ever introduction to the rules of criminal procedure, and a case that hinges on properly introduced expert tes­timony


In fact, it's said that the film's director has a law degree, and insisted that court proceedings be accurate.

Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals judge Richard Posner, in his book "Law and Literature" wrote that

My Cousin Vinny is particularly rich in practice tips: how a criminal defense lawyer must stand his ground against a hostile judge, even at the cost of exasperating the judge, because the lawyer's primary audience is the jury, not the judge; how cross-examination on peripheral matters can sow serious doubts about a witness's credibility; how props can be used effectively in cross-examination (the tape measure that demolishes one of the prosecution's eyewitnesses); how to voir dire, examine, and cross-examine expert witnesses; the importance of the Brady doctrine ... how to dress for a trial; contrasting methods of conducting a jury trial; and more.

In other words, "My Cousin Vinny" is a movie directed by an accredited legal expert, which is often lauded over by other legal professionals across the field, and to this day. So its audience is pretty sophisticated.

http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GD6qtc2_AQA/maxresdefault.jpg

--
There's no such thing as the establishment. Everyone knows that!

reply

Well, there you go. Guess old Charlie Nesson wasn't the crazy pothead we presumed lol.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply