MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Why are so many films based in New York?...

Why are so many films based in New York?


No offence to New Yorkers, great city, but Hollywood is far from it, why are so many movies set there I wonder?

reply

Seems to be a trend. New York has a cultural aspect to it that might be symbolized as American city life of industrialism/arts/history/culture or some other aspect/tone of that nature.

"The city that never sleeps."

Many media and people have likened New York as one of the "the" cities that has a major element or aspect of U.S. culture or life. Also, it being a state with a massive population squeezed in to one small region makes it have a bigger sway in ways when it comes to culture too.

The whole New York symbolism is a lot like Toronto in Canada where it is also a culturally tied place of Ontario known as "the six."

Of course these result in stereotypes which then enables people to assume all Americans or such are just like those they encountered at 'X' place and 'Y' time or such.

Basically New York has the record of being a "hot spot" in the U.S. along with L.A., Houston, Miami, etc. Since it has this major cultural and social identity to it, it oftentimes is probably used as a "stock locale" for works/fiction/etc. due to its pull/name popularity as well.

reply

Yeah, too bad it doesn't represent America as a whole. NYC is about as representative of America as a whole as much as London represents all of England.

reply

Old Blue Eyes tells it...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EEjq8ZoyXuQ

reply

It is a place of endless possibilities...

reply

That's because many tv/film writers live in New York City, so they're more inclined to write stories that take place in the Big Apple. It's also why you see suburbanites erroneously written to look, dress, and act like Jersey Shore socialites. Because that's as close as the city slicker writers will get to seeing what the suburbs are like, so they just assume it's all like that, hence the fake look to it.

reply

Lol is there such a thing as jersey shore socialites?

reply

Yep. Where do you think they got the inspiration for the show with the same name?

reply

"as close as the city slicker writers will get to seeing what the suburbs are like,"

There are plenty of New York suburbs in New York. There are working-class suburbs like Yonkers, middle-class suburbs like Westchester and rich suburbs like the Hamptons. There are also suburban-like areas within the city in parts of Queens and Staten Island. They're all just a train ride away.

I don't think any self-respecting socialite would live in New Jersey. Jersey Shore folks are not socialites.

reply

After accurately fleshing out NY, you pigeonhole NJ.

reply

I know, New Jersey gets no respect. Sorry Jersey! Regular New Yorkers look down upon NJ. Socialites are much worst since they're about image and position. To be fair, socialites wouldn't live in the outer boroughs of NYC. Maybe Brooklyn since it's become trendy, but that's iffy.

reply

I get the distinct feeling that you're unaware of some areas of NJ. But the rich don't share the same ignorance.

reply

Most rich people are not socialites. I know there are wealthy areas in Jersey. I insist that socialites in the region prefer to live in Manhattan.

I'm not sure if you're aware that it's common to hate New Jersey and it's the butt of jokes going back at least decades. It's countrywide, but especially in NYC. Part of it had to do with all the chemicals polluting the area and unsafe water.

Just a simple google and look what pops-up:
https://www.google.com/search?q=new+york+hates+new+jersey%27&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b-1

reply

I've lived in the NYC/Metro area my whole life -- so I'm quite aware of the jeering (and it's not about chemicals). I grew up in Bergen County, NJ about 5 mins from Alpine, and I lived downtown in the same building where Paris Hilton once lived (on Astor Place -- but not the new one she bought a few years ago). Do you live here?

But I think we need to define our term: Socialite

you first


reply

"so I'm quite aware of the jeering"

You realize that we're in agreement, right?

But, I'll add it is the chemicals, too. NJ was known for being toxic especially the water. BTW, it's not helping your argument considering people in Newark can't drink the water.

Socialite:
Family listed in the social register. Old money. WASP elite. Last two loosening up a little. Spend a few hundred thousand attending galas and charities wearing designer clothes and associating with others in high society. Emphasis on the socializing in regard to socialite.

Google "New Jersey Socialite" and you'll see zip. Then google "New York Socialite" and you'll see pages of names listed.

reply

Before I reply...

You didn't answer. Are you from here? Live(d) here? Work here? Stayed here?

I can use shorthand rather than spelling it all out depending on your answer.



reply

Let's say I know the area. You can use shorthand.

reply


Yonkers is the 4th biggest city in New York State with a population pushing 200,000 over 18 square miles...It's in Westchester County on the NYC border
Westchester is the County with some of the highest real estate prices in the world...you'd have to go to LA or Tokyo to spend more per square foot or in taxes

Frankly, it's all a big rip off
The schools are awful and the taxes are too high near the city outside of exclusive areas like Scarsdale (you need to REALLY clock to own there!)

Most everyone I know moved an hour away...

reply

I'd expect you to be an expert on Yonkers considering your username.

My relative complained about the high rent in Ossining before moving out of NY. It makes sense if the working-class are being pushed out now since it's a closer commute for anyone who works in NYC. Much of Westchester was always pricey.

I don't know the reason, but most people I know refer to Yonkers as Yonkers and farther north as Westchester.

It's sick how much people are spending for housing now. NY is a rip-off which is why so many move out when they retire.

reply

b/c it's like having another compelling character in your film. it's a draw all on its own.

reply

I appreciate the replies, thanks, from over here it just looks like all of America is based in New York , it would perhaps be nice to see more films set in the South , like the phenomenal True Detective Season 1 !

reply

Love s1 true detective. I can give you some good films set in the south, there are plenty. Black Snake Moan sums up the dirty south pretty well.

reply

To Kill A Mockingbird

reply

This all day. Serpico? Dog Day Afternoon? Pacino is great, but NY is the lead in both of these flicks. I love this answer dmac.

reply

Great tax breaks and other perks for filming in NY and they actively court the film industry. Georgia does the same which is why so many shows are filmed there, too.

reply

I think this is one of the main reasons.

reply

Toronto and Vancouver does this.

reply

The cultural and economic capital of the USA.

reply

The scenery and locations can be moody (the Central Park showdown at the end of Wall Street for instance) and sometimes very pretty in NYC (ariel
views of the Hudson River and the harbor come to mind)

They DO pretty the place up in a lot of movies...there is litter and dog poop everywhere and the rats are common here
And you can't walk twenty feet without a bum asking for a buck or a 'rapper' trying to sell you a demo tape on the corner

New York often looks way better on film

reply

In the case of action movies with big battle sequences, the sheer size and the density of the buildings makes for a dramatic aftermath.

reply

I think my favourite film set in New York was Trading Places, absolutely hilarious film, and on the horror side it has to be the original Jacobs Ladder.

reply