Loved it; loved it.


Didn't know about or expect this confection, came upon TCM at just the right moment while surfing. Lucky me. I loved it. Some clever writing well delivered. William Powell was still in love with his persona, that urbane roué business; his performance felt very fresh. Ann Harding was lovely, she may have stolen the show from him. It was like one of those old drawing room plays; maybe it had been. Did notice (I thought)it was mostly her own hair and that Powell was decidedly not trim.

reply

Just saw this movie a day or so ago and I find it haunting my memory! The dialogue was so modern, I wondered at the time if it would seem as contemporary in another 70 years. Ann Harding's performance was so sincere and appealing -- how could Powell NOT find her irresistable! And, she re-invigorated his business life by providing strategic advice, we presume -- how cool is that for 1933. And that final line while the screen blacked-out (or whatever the official directing term may be) -- what a belly laugh that brought for me! "He must have been away for those 4 months!" Classic!!!

reply

Powell and Harding are so good....but Lucile Brown as Valerie is SO bad...her line readings are terrible. Wasn't there someone to help her? Or is this the result of all the help and it's the best she could do?

Interesting film. I enjoyed it very much.

reply

I loved it as well. Powell is as debonaire as ever and Harding is a perfect match for him. I need to find this one on DVD!

reply

I agree with all of you. In the scenes with Ann Harding and William Powell, you forget that it is the early 1930s. They seem so alive and modern. In scenes with other cast members, you do realize by the method of acting and the words that it was many years ago.

Both Ms. Harding and Mr. Powell are amazingly appealing no matter what their roles, and together, they had the same chemisty as Cary Grant and Irene Dunne in their comedies.

reply

Just saw this for the first time! on the TCM Vault Collection DVD! A very nice package, with restored footage (the seduction/entrapment scene!) and it's wonderful!

I concur with all the other posters regarding the lovely chemistry, poise and astute acting from Ms. Harding and Mr. Powell! Wonderfully masterful to behold.

I thought the Valerie character was good when it counted. Her scene where she spills the beans on Joan's plot was very good I thought. Her character was pretty bratty and supercilious, and maybe, had she been a stronger actor, could have shown some more depth and interesting colors. Some of her other moments were less refined. Lilian Bond came off quite well. The other performances were fine. But, clearly, Ann Harding and William Powell really carried the day! I wish that they had done many more films together!

The whole thing was rather smart and thoroughly engrossing.

The ending and wrap-up came a little too abruptly making me wish that it had gone on a bit longer.

reply

In the beginning and for most of the film, I disliked Powell's smug, disingenuous remarks to Joan (Harding) and was wishing she would stand up a bit more for herself. Especially when the brat of a sister enters who definitely needs a clack. Would have liked to see her get a bit more comeuppance before the movie ended. In fact, I really didn't blame Joan for her end around tactic to ensnare Powell, especially considering his celebratory attitudes towards bachelorhood. Of course, in the end, Powell grows up and grows into a fine marriage with a lovely, supportive woman.

reply

I joined this film "in progress" as they say, and when I heard Lucile Browne simpering, I had to check to be sure it wasn't Bette Davis. I half expected to hear her say "when I kissed ya, I wiped my mouth."


We are like the dreamer who dreams and then lives in the dream

reply