MovieChat Forums > Modern Times (1936) Discussion > Would the original ending have worked?

Would the original ending have worked?


MODERN TIMES originally ended with the Tramp and the Gamine being separated forever. She becomes a nun while he's in the hospital. As he walks into the sunset alone, she sadly imagines her younger self running after him, but remains with her order.

Personally, I find this ending needlessly grim and inorganic to the story. The more optmistic finale works so much better. Anyone agree or do you think the original ending could have worked?

reply