MovieChat Forums > The Shop Around the Corner (1940) Discussion > Anonymous letter about Mrs. M...

Anonymous letter about Mrs. M...


Am I the only one who thinks it was Pepi that wrote the anonymous letter about Mrs. M to Mr. M? (Mr. M talked about it in his hospital bed to mr. Kralik) I may be biased though...Pepi is my favorite character.

reply

I've never thought about it, but that makes perfect sense!

reply

Yeah,

I'm pretty sure Pepi was the author. As he says he was frequently making deliveries to the owner's wife he would have had a chance to see that she was having an affair. But, there is something about the Pepi character that bothers me. He acts so strange after he gets promoted to clerk. I was almost expecting for it turn out that he made up the whole thing to get a promotion.

On another note, Rudy the new delivery boy says "my kind are not allowed to live in town"...was this a suggestion that Rudy was Jewish?

reply

Pepi could have been the author... Also why did the employees act appalled by Pepi being promoted to clerk, with Pirovich saying "Who did this dreadful thing?"

reply

I think they were just winding him up a bit. I don't think they really thought it was "dreadful".

“I always tell the truth…even when I lie” - Scarface

reply


I don't think Pepi is a possibility, because most of the time Pepi complains about Mrs. Matuschek.

Mrs. Matuschek is attracted to the person who has money and style. For Example, the scene where Vadas pays the taxi driver the money and tip. And the camera focuses on the money.

Pirovitch says "Maybe he (Mr. Matuschek) has some trouble with his wife." And Vadas comes and asks "Is he in trouble with his wife?"

In the beginning, Vadas says this too "I think Mrs. Matuschek is a very charming woman."

reply

"I don't think Pepi is a possibility, because most of the time Pepi complains about Mrs. Matuschek."

All the more reason for him to want to expose her secret affair- to get back at her for being such a thoughtless cow.



“I always tell the truth…even when I lie” - Scarface

reply


Oh yeah. Thanks for explaining to me. So I now think Pepi is a possibility.

reply

On another note, Rudy the new delivery boy says "my kind are not allowed to live in town"...was this a suggestion that Rudy was Jewish?


It suggests your hearing might need checking. What he says is: 'My people [i.e., his family, not his ethnic group] don't live here in town.'

reply

Pepi was a jerk. I thought Rudy said "my people don't live here in town". I've seen this movie lots of times and I don't remember him saying "my kind are not allowed to live in town".

I'll tell you in another life, when we are both cats.

reply

Surely the implication can still be there in a subtle way?

reply

No, why would there? Jews were definitely allowed to live in Budapest. The writer of the play was a Jew who was born and raised in Budapest himself. It seems Rudi originally came from the country or something and moved to the big city to make money.

reply

[deleted]

I think it's pretty obviously Pirovich.

reply

[deleted]

Did the author have to be someone who worked in the shop?

reply

No, it would probably be a neighbor (some of which notice comings and goings)or friend (or Pepi being out and about a lot) who happened to chance upon it. The clerks all keep pretty long hours although Pirovich mentions he lives 2 blocks or so away from 'the boss'.

I also found Pepi to be irritating, but he was supposed to be (IMO).

Having a history with the clerks, and his being annoying with an exaggerated sense of self importance was the reason IMO the clerks reacted to his promotion in such a way. If not the scene would have illustrated winks to each other or other signs they were just kidding, but didn't notice any.

Vesele Vianoce!!!! http://www.iarelative.com/czech/xmas/index.html

reply

[deleted]

And ....Pepe didn't exactly try to hide what he knew from the other clerks!
"Draw your own conclusions."

reply

If Pepi wrote the letter, he'd have had Mr. M's death on his conscience for life if he hadn't walked in when he did. He must have expected him to be angry, not despondent.

I'm all right, I'm alllll right!

reply