B+W or colour


I watched this the other evening on TCM, & it was shown in colour when it states on IMDB that it was filmed in B&W.As it is noir I thought it unusual,but it was still an enjoyable film

reply

never seen it in color. if you recorded it, i would love a copy.

reply

Why the hell would you want to watch a film noir in color. By most accounts, color takes the noir out of noir.

reply


I saw this too. Was a colourised version of the film, that is at some stage colour has been added, it seems pointless to me. When they do this to a b/w film it never looks right. Great film anyway.

reply

it probably matches the cover of the VHS. i want to see this version.

reply

I can not imagine why anyone who loves cinema would ever want to see a colorized version of any b&w film

reply

I had no idea there was a version in colour that existed. Don't know how I'd feel about that, but is it fairly easy to get?

What we got here...is failure to communicate.

reply

I'm watching the colour version on the MGM channel (New Zealand) right now. I could instantly tell it was a colourized version because it has it has that pasty look to it. But you're right, it's still an enjoyable film. Funnily enough, I think that the faded, pastel colours make the film seem older than it already is- it has the look of a 1930's colour film, like Becky Sharp.

Fiddle-dee-dee!

reply

As a rule of thumb, the less changes made to a film after completion the better.

As a matter of principal, I won't watch a "colorized" version of anything...



"She's my sister... [slap]
She's my daughter... [slap]
My sister, my daughter [slap]
[slap]"

reply

I'll watch a colorized version of the Marx Brothers or Laurel and Hardy - that would be super!

reply

In colour? Ugh....it's a black and white film! Why did they show it in colour? Sad.

If a movie is filmed in black and white, then I want to see it ONLY in black and white.

~~
JimHutton (1934-79) & ElleryQueen

reply

Here's a clip on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_-k4dlA-dw

reply

[deleted]

Just watched that youtube clip. Don't like it in colour! Black and White all the way.





http://onlinedollars.siterubix.com/

reply

I used to hate the colorization of B&W films, but over time, I have enjoyed colorized films as much and often MORE than the original. Think of it logically people: Color is more REALISTIC than B&W, but I think the B&W lovers enjoy the MOOD or FANTASY that B&W conveys.

reply