MovieChat Forums > The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948) Discussion > Didn't The Bandits Know It Was Gold?

Didn't The Bandits Know It Was Gold?


When it's in that form does it have to be refined? Why didm't the bandits know what it was? They're bandits!

Every third person who complains will be shot. Two people have complained already!

reply

I was wondering if the old man was crazy and it really was sand in the bags.

reply

Why didn't the bandits know what it was? They're bandits!


I think that in the film (although definitely in the novel) Howard explains to his partners that to inexperienced eyes, unrefined gold looks like plain sand. Therefore the bandits wouldn't have realized what was really inside the sacks because they're bandits, without the experience of prospecting for gold.

Most great films deserve a more appreciative audience than they get.

reply

I don't know. After watching several seasons of "Gold Rush", I don't know how anyone could make that mistake. Gold flakes are pretty much unmistakable for anything else. Not to mention the weight alone would be much greater than sand. I suppose in their rush to find something valuable, they didn't look too closely at what they had.

And, it is an important plot device so I can overlook that small flaw in the movie.



Democracy is the pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance. H.L. Mencken

reply

Remember that the bandits were desperate, and figured they hit a mother lode with the pelts and the burros they could now sell. They didn't take the time to feel or examine the bags, and probably didn't think much about watching the, uh, sand, as it filtered out in the wind.

BTW (spoiler for the book): In the book by B Traven (published 1927), Howard and Curtin find a little bit of gold that hasn't blown away. Not a lot, but maybe $3,500 worth, which in 1927 was about two years salary for a typical U.S. worker with a decent job.

reply

It is explained in the movie that the bandits thought the sand was there to add weight to the furs.

reply