MovieChat Forums > Titanic (1953) Discussion > Why was the iceberg strike 'flipped' in ...

Why was the iceberg strike 'flipped' in the underwater shot?


As is known, and shown in this film, the Titanic hit the berg on its starboard (right) side. But the underwater shot of the ship being ripped open by the berg shows it hitting it on its port (left) side.

This has been noted and commented upon ever since the film came out 56 years ago, but as far as I know never explained. It has always frustrated viewers as one of the most blatant and baffling contradictions within any film. (If they had shown the ship striking the berg on its port above water, that would have been factually inaccurate but would at least have matched the ensuing scenes.)

Subsequent to this shot, all the interior and exterior shots of the ship clearly show a list to port, which was of course historically incorrect. The very first interior shot, of crewmen running out of a hold as the hull is torn open, comports with a portside strike but that shot too looks "flipped", as if it had been filmed correctly (a starboard hit), but then reversed when it was printed to conform with this inexplicable portside gash. Take a look at it next time -- it clearly looks like a mirror image. And as the model sinks it's shown listing to port; close-ups of the passengers on the decks and crew on the bridge also plainly depict a decided tilt to port.

My question is -- how did this happen? How did one mistake someplace in the production balloon into this massively unfathomable series of absurdly depicted errors? No answer I can come up with makes satisfactory sense. Somebody screwed up badly at some point, but the decision was obviously made, not to fix the initial mistake, but to change the entire depiction of the sinking into something not only inaccurate but idiotic, to go along as though the ship's port side was damaged, even though the surface scenes of the ship hitting the berg totally contradict everything that comes after. This is such a massive mistake and utterly asinine method of dealing with the situation that it's astounding the brains behind the movie didn't take steps to properly correct it. Nothing about this makes any sense.

So -- anybody have any information as to how and why this ludicrous situation came about?

reply

I can't answer why the iceberg hit on the wrong side, but the real Titanic did list to port. She initially listed slightly to starboard right after the collision, but as the ship flooded, the water made its way port and started flooding "Scotland Road," a passage way that ran nearly the length of the ship. When that started flooding, the list shifted to port and became very noticeable as the sinking unfolded, even impacting the lifeboat launching.

It is really baffling that the damage occurs on the wrong side in this movie. That is one of the staple pieces of information about the sinking and has NEVER been in question. Very strange.

reply

Interesting info about the effects the flooding along Scotland Road had on the list. I don't recall ever reading anything about the direction of Titanic's list. Even so, in this film, the depiction of the port side being torn open below water, even as the ship was passing the berg on her starboard side, is simply inexplicable. I sometimes wonder whether they built the model incorrectly, with the port side able to be "opened" and flooded, and so had to account for its resultant list to port? I don't think this was the case at all, but something went terribly wrong. If you're correct about the list, showing the ship underwater striking the berg where no berg actually existed is even more senseless.

Not to mention that the gigantic [or should I say "Britannic"?] gash opened up in the movie model was so ludicrously huge and catastrophic that the ship would have almost capsized, and certainly sunk within minutes, not 2 hours 40. It looked really cool, though.

reply

[deleted]

My guess is that the underwater shot and scene of the interior being opened to the sea is simply an editing error -the shot got flipped and nobody noticed in time. With the scene showing the (model) ship striking the starboard side, it really couldn't have been anything else but a mistake in editing.

The scenes of the ship listing slightly to port was indeed something that happened during the sinking.

reply

It's a terrible goof, I watched it for the last time last night and could not believe the scene was left in the final edit.

-I guess I'm just not used to being chased round a mall in the middle of the night by killer robots

reply