Pilot episode re-filmed


Who here thinks they should've re-filmed the unaired pilot for the first broadcast episode?

reply

I really like Two on a Raft as the series starter. I've only watched Marooned twice, and didn't find it very funny. So if they re-filmed it with the same plot and jokes, it would probably be only marginally better with Tina, Dawn, and Russell.

That's why I'm not a big fan of BGF FGT either, which uses scenes from the pilot as flashbacks (and re-creates a few as well).

reply

I think you could probably cut "Marooned," "Two on a Raft" and "Birds Gotta Fly, Fish Gotta Talk" into one fairly seamless pilot episode, ending with the "Gilligan, one smart Marubi," sequence. It'd probably be close to an hour long. The only thing really missing would be some kind of transition between Gilligan destroying the transmitter (after it is recovered) and the Skipper cooking eggs the next morning.

We're it up to me, I'd trim down all the slapstick on the raft a bit at the same time. As with Gilligan's fishing sequence from the pilot, it just goes on a just bit too long.

reply

I'd love to see someone do that. Edit thouse three episodes into one. Sadly, i am not good at stuff like that.

reply

I really like Two on a Raft as the series starter. I've only watched Marooned twice, and didn't find it very funny.

I've never seen the episode and I don't think I want to as it is a failed pilot. The pilot was rejected and the series was recast after studio executives reluctantly changed their minds.

I feel bad for John Gabriel and the other actors who were replaced and I also feel bad it was filmed under such trying circumstances.

That episode was filmed immediately after the JFK assassination. It must have been awful to be in Hawaii filming a slapstick comedy and get the news. To continue filming the episode must have been very difficult.

reply

Something I would like to see (if it exists) is the footage that Sherwood removed from his first cut of the pilot. Supposedly, there was footage shot at Honolulu Harbor that introduced all of the Castaways. Of course, this would have featured the three alternate cast members.

I don't know what, if anything, else was removed from the first cut of the pilot.

reply

According to Sherwood you wouldn't wanna see it. In his book he called that opening scene "four minutes of dull footage that could only make an audience tune out."  Those clips we see in the original theme song are probably the only things that exist.

He claimed that was the only 'big' chunk of footage that was cut. Any other editing was simply done to reconstruct or trim certain scenes (and in one case, lengthen -- Gilligan's battle with the shark).

At the same time, he joked that at one point there were so many different versions of different scenes, there was enough film in the editing room "to make Gilligan's Island an 84-part mini series."

reply

I wish the pilot episode featured more of the castaways before getting on the tour boat

reply