MovieChat Forums > Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea (1964) Discussion > Wait - Stanley Kubrick ripped off Voyage...

Wait - Stanley Kubrick ripped off Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea?


Say it ain't so! Actually I don't say it's so, but there is some mysterious similarities. Sn 1 Ep. 18 "The Human Computer," bears some striking similarities to 2001, especially when you consider this episode was aired on 15 February 1965, when Kubrick would have been in pre-production for 2001. You think I'm crazy? Well then

Consider the plot: a ship is completely under control of a newly installed computer and is capable of entirely running the ship. No crew is on board except for Capt. Crane. Another point is that during the conference before hand, the scientist tells Adm. Nelson that the technological breakthrough needed to make this computer possible wasn't expected for another twenty years. Since the show is set in the mid 1970's (well sometimes it is, it seems to vary quite a bit), that would mean the expected breakthrough should have occurred sometime in the mid 1990's - right when HAL was first operational! Who's crazy now?

There's even a scene where Capt. Crane is playing chess. (Okay, he is playing against himself and not the computer). But still ... And this computer didn't have a name, and it doesn't go crazy and try to kill everyone. Maybe I am crazy after all.

Somewhat interestingly, the scriptwriter, Robert Hamner, also wrote the script for Star Trek's "A Taste of Armageddon", a story that involved two planets who conducted their war solely with computers. This guy must have had a thing against computers. I wonder if years later he ever finally gave in and used a word processor, or if he stuck to his typewriter. At least typewriters are plotting to take over the world and destroy humanity like computers are. I once saw a documentary on that very subject. I think it was called something like Terminator.


_______________________________________
Resolutely Analog In A Digital World!

reply

....hmmmm.....food for thought. Hadn't realized the similarities. But it is there!

reply

Somewhat interestingly, the scriptwriter, Robert Hamner, also wrote the script for Star Trek's "A Taste of Armageddon", a story that involved two planets who conducted their war solely with computers. - A_Dude_Named_Dude


Speaking of Star Trek, The Ultimate Computer (1968) is similar to The Human Computer (1965) in more ways than just the title. In the Trek episode the Enterprise is also fully automated by a new computer system and goes off with a skeleton crew for testing/war games.

reply

I thought the same thing about this VTTBOTS episode, that it was practically the same as the ST-TOS episode! Even the computer went crazy.

reply

I thought the same thing about this VTTBOTS episode, that it was practically the same as the ST-TOS episode! - lauriegonzalez11


It'll be deja vu all all over again when you watch Cradle of the Deep (1965) - it features a giant amoeba, just like The Immunity Syndrome (1968)!

reply

Kubrick based 2001 on a Clarke story named THE SENTINEL-he then asked Clarke to expand upon the theme

reply