A Man who lost it all


I grew up in Fairfield, an area the resides right next door to Westport where most of The Swimmer was filmed. This movie, like the Ice Storm, is an accurate portrayal of wealthy people from Connecticut. Last night it was on Turner Classic Movies. It was presented as one of comedian Gilbert Godfrey’s favorite films, which I found really interesting. I agree with Godfrey when he said the film is hypnotic. Obviously it has a 1960s feel with the way it was filmed and edited, but so what! That is what makes it so dreamlike. I think with this film you either get it or you don’t. It is that simple. I think it is probably one of the best films about the male ego in a suburbia setting ever made. I also think Burt Lancaster should’ve won a second Academy Award for his bold acting choices.

I have read the great short story a long time ago. The film compliments the short story very accurately. In some ways, it betters it. The scene with the underrated and sexy Janice Rule is so well done, it makes me think that she should've been nominated for a supporting actress that year. If Beatrice Straight can win an award for her short scene in Network, why not Janice Rule for her short and powerful scene in The Swimmer?

If you like this film, I would also recommend F. Scott Fitzgerald's two great short stories Winter Dreams and Babylon Revisited. Robert Olen Butler's story Jealous Husband Returns in the Form of a Parrot is another short story that weirdly reminds of The Swimmer. I would also recommend reading Hemingway's short story, The Snows of Kilimanjaro. These stories are all about broken men past their prime slowly coming to terms with their pasts.

reply

How did it end? I fell
Asleep

reply

I can't believe you would say it complements the story accurately, or even "betters it".

I was eager to see this after reading the Cheever story (or, more precisely, hearing it read on the New Yorker fiction podcast). But I thought Lancaster was poorly cast as the patrician WASP, many of the subtleties were underlined in bold in the film, the sequence of events was screwed up (unlike in the story, he encounters someone hostile to him *before* arriving at other parties where he is greeted warmly), and the former babysitter who came along with him was an unnecessary addition that undermined the basic nature of the quest as described in the story.

There were also some risible 1960s style "surreal" film effects, and a jarring score. 5/10 for me, adapted from a 9/10 story.

--------
Daily single-tweet movie reviews: https://twitter.com/SlackerInc

reply

His neighbours were *beeps*, all they wanted to do with kick him whilst he was done and remind him of his short-comings. Seems that empathy is in short supply in the suburbs. Sure he probably had it all coming to him but they could have shown some compassion, given the obvious distress he is in. He must not have behaved very well in the past and probably treated them like **** too but they could have at least shown him some kindness.

reply