MovieChat Forums > Harold and Maude (1971) Discussion > Harold's mother's reaction to the news h...

Harold's mother's reaction to the news he had been killed


When I watched it before (and this seems the general view) I believed that seeing his mother's shock when she believes he has been killed led to him continually trying to recreate that reaction. But watching it again I paid closer attention to Harold's description of her behavior at the time. He said she put a hand to her face and her other hand went out to the side and she collapsed into the arms of the people who had told her. Doesn't that sound rather theatrical? Almost as if she was acting in some old melodrama. Yet the whole scenario only makes sense if he believed she was genuinely upset.

reply

But watching it again I paid closer attention to Harold's description of her behavior at the time. He said she put a hand to her face and her other hand went out to the side and she collapsed into the arms of the people who had told her. Doesn't that sound rather theatrical? Almost as if she was acting in some old melodrama. Yet the whole scenario only makes sense if he believed she was genuinely upset.


My take was that her reaction to his "death" was genuine and Harold's description makes it seem more melodramatic than it probably was. I think Harold's "performances" are his attempts to re-experience that moment of true emotional response that he got from his mother. Unfortunately, it no longer has any effect.

reply

My take was that he thought her reaction was theatrical and he was doing it over and over trying to get a real authentic emotional reaction from her.

reply

That is why he kept committing suicide for her viewing "pleasure". That is what filled him with such pain. His mother didn't care at all that he had been killed accidentally in the explosion. Her reaction was Broadway, and he knew it. She faked any emotion whatsoever that she had lost her son, and he saw that and realised she did not feel a single thing for him. Hence dramatically killing himself always in sight of her, becoming more graphic and over the top with each attempt, JUST to see if anything real came out of her. The closest he got was the bathtub suicide. That's about as real as she got, but that was in complaint or exhaustion with the whole suicide attempt scenario. She was clearly shaken by it, but not in the way he wants. He wants her to actually care about him. And she doesn't. It's blatantly clear when he tells Maude this story that what truly wounds him the greatest, is that his mother is just going through the motions. He's just property, like her possessions.

reply

Excellent post, VoodooGuru. And I thought he was being cruel with this whole "suicide attempt scenario".


☁☀☁

------__@
----_`\<,_
___(*)/ (*)____
» nec spe,nec metu •´¯`» I've been tasting roads my whole life. http://i.imgur.com/hhu3ivw.gif

reply

Thanks Bree ;)

reply