MovieChat Forums > Harold and Maude (1971) Discussion > Why does Harold visit funerals?

Why does Harold visit funerals?


I understand that Harold is obsessed with death. And, it seems his fixation is tied to his desire to be noticed. (He discusses with Maude the moment his mom was convinced he died.) To Harold, death may be a way to get people to care.

So, if attention and concern are his reasons for being interested in death, why does he go to the funerals? It would make sense to me if he found death, itself, interesting, and goes to funerals to observe that state. But, that is not the case from what I see. Also, Maude teaches him the importance of recognizing individuality, when pointing out the differences between daisies. Since Harold learns to appreciate the beauty of each person later on in the movie, I do not think he visits funerals out of respect for the person who has passed away.

reply

I think because he feels he can relate to the deceased, like Maude side, 'a lot of people enjoy being dead, but they're not really dead, they're just hiding from life', as he was.

reply

Okay. Yes. His connection to death is more than attention-seeking.

Maybe I need to re-watch this movie, but I didn't see Harold as someone who was afraid to live. He just seemed apathetic to, and rebellious against, his surroundings, which consisted of his histrionic mother, a doctor, and random dates. I see Maude as someone who encouraged him to be more proactive in life.

reply

It depends on how you define live. Like in Highlander, Lord Byron says to Methos 'do you want a tombstone that says he lived for 300 years? Or one that says for 300 years, he was alive?' Harold wasn't alive in that sense, he was holding back from life, he enjoyed nothing, the only thing he lived for was to draw a reaction out of his mother, which he couldn't do anymore because she'd become desensitized to his suicides. As such, he could no longer get any REAL attention from her, and he never sought out anybody else to receive attention from, but Maude noticed him and she gave him that attention he needed, that connection to another living human being, a REAL human being, she was a sunflower, not the daisy, not 'all alike', who don't have time for anyone that's different than they are.

reply

Hm. I realize I may've been making excuses for Harold's behavior. "Hiding from life" and "holding back" imply that he's deliberately avoiding experience. I thought that Harold may not have known what he was missing, and Maude simply exposes him to the world. But, then I think of Harold's situation. Like you said, his main thrill is shocking his mother. Other than that, he goes to funerals and demolition sites. We don't see him talking to others, working, engaging in hobbies, etc. At his character's age, it's likely he's making a choice to avoid experience.

reply

Harold's obsession with death had a lot of reasons, as some have mentioned one of the reasons was to grab his mother's attention for the only time she showed true loving affection and emotion for him was when she thought he had died, other is because he could relate with people who were dead mainly because he felt he was also dead.

The point where he saw his mother's reaction probably made him realise that he was more appreciated by her when he was dead, but let's take a moment and think about the scene where his mother is answering the questions for the Online Dating for him, she doesn't know anything about him and doesn't even bother to aknowledge his existence on this even though it's his life. She simply answers as herself which in my opinion showed me he never truly lived because he was, as Maude in one scene mentions "caged", trapped in a cage where his life was being dictated by his mother.

I have an interpretation that says when he finally saw an actual emotion from his mother he started rebelling against not just her but life itself because he felt like there was no point in living since no one seemed to care about him, I bet even before his obsession with death he was already weird, unsocial and a quiet person especially when someone is controlling his life - Not bashing his mother, she seemed to truly care for him but was more concerned about her life with him around rather than his own life.

Harold was trapped in a life that didn't belong to his, he had no control over whatsoever until he discovered he could "die" over and over and over and experience his mother's reaction until she stopped caring. At which point he seemed to just prefer the experience of dying because it was part of his life and probably the major thing he could take control of. Also because he liked the feeling of being "dead"

You could argue that he had control over his life, as he had his own car and went out a lot of times for the funerals and so on... but I think this was after the constant "killing himself" which enfatuaded his mother and she began to stop caring even more but still control his life only not to the point of what she did before finding out about his "death"

Just my interpretation though :)

reply

The key scene in the film is when Harold breaks down and sobs while relating how his mother reacted to hearing that he had been killed in a lab explosion. She responded in a stagy manner, that is to say, it was a performance without any true feeling to it. When Harold saw this, he knew she didn't love him, or at least, couldn't express it, and Harold became grief stricken because of it, as evinced by him sobbing when he recollected the moment. Those suicide performances, initially, were probably attempts to break through to her feelings, which he failed to do. Later, we see that these performances became more passive aggressively directed at her.

And so, he probably went to funerals to be around genuine grief so as to numb his own. Watching buildings be demolished is also sort of sad, especially in cities where there are usually nothing wrong with the buildings, they're just torn down to make room for something newer.

Mind you, this is just some psychological opinion as it wasn't clarified in the film but it works for me in gaining some understanding.


"Bemusement, my favourite form of musement"

reply