'Why?' 'Because we can.'


Towards the end of the movie whenever Joanna arrives rain soaked at the Men's Club and confronts Dale,(Diz)Coba and asks him, "Why?", his response is, "Because we can". Just before that though, he tries to convince her that she doesn't need the fireplace tool (that she's holding in her hand) as a weapon and tells her that she's imagined it all wrong. That "it's" just another stage and that they've found a way that's best for them and "it's" best for her (and for all the women). Then, the true process of "Stepfordization" is revealed to the viewer.
I have not read the novel. My question is this: In the book, is there more conversation between Diz and Joanna (or some other information given) in which we get more of an understanding as to why he would think that the "next stage" is better for the women themselves?

reply

There is no semi-explanation in the book, neither is there a confirmation to Joanna's fears. She also doesn't face off with Dale.

What happens is that she lured to meet Bobbie so that Bobbie can prove to her that the robot thing is not true.

The next chapter, Joanna has been changed.

reply

Thank you kaskait for your answer. I suppose the scene was added as a timely devise to amplify the angst associated with the feminist movement. Well, at the risk of dragging this on, does Joanna ever stab Bobbie like she did in the movie in order to confirm her suspicions?

reply

I don't know why the film creators decided not to be ambiguous like the book. It seems as if they were playing with the drug angle because the film shows Dale Coba's company as biochemical company (scene in which Joanna's car passes corporate offices at the end).

In the book the men tell Joanna that Bobbie will prove that she is human by cutting her hand. The scene leaves off at that with the men waiting outside Bobbie's house.

reply

In the book, Joanna is taken by the men to Bobbie's house. They tell her that Bobbie will prove she is human and the robot idea is all nonsense. The t.v. is turned up very loud upstairs so the kids can't hear what is about to happen. The men wait outside on the porch. Bobbie is going to kill Joanna. The men stand out there and talk. "What is taking so long?" Next thing we see is the new robot Joanna. She no longer has any interest in photography, telling the new resident in town, "There is just so much to do around the house." There is much more storyline about the new woman, Ruthanne - the black woman. In the film we only see her arguing with her husband in the supermarket. In the book, she had become friends with Joanna until Joanna was changed, just as Joanna had been friends with Bobbie before she was changed. In the end of the book, Ruthanne's husband tells her he doesn't mind her taking time away from him for her writing. After all, they are going away for the weekend soon. He knows she will soon be a robot and not interested in writing anymore. He is able to bide his time. This is why Walter told Joanna that the men's association will accept women in 6 months or so. Was never going to happen. He was just placating her until they got the robot ready to take her place. Say anything to keep it all calm temporarily.

reply

Joanna should have rammed that poker across Diz's head, just as she did with Walter.

reply

This is why Walter told Joanna that the men's association will accept women in 6 months or so. Was never going to happen. He was just placating her until they got the robot ready to take her place.

Yes, just saw it again last night. 6 months can be an eternity, if you know what I mean.

"It's the system, Lara. People will be different after the Revolution."

reply