MovieChat Forums > National Lampoon's Vacation (1983) Discussion > "I had a pooch like this" makes no sense

"I had a pooch like this" makes no sense


"I had a pooch"...

(though anthromorphizing, 'cutesy' word that animals should not be thought of as, because they're animals first. Animal, species, breed, THEN 'name', but people always think of especially 'pet animals' as 'little humans' and every single hag that does this thinks they are being completely unique and original in doing so)..

...might make some kind of sense, but I had a pooch LIKE THIS doesn't.

So, he's holding up just the leash and says 'pooch like this'. Like what? What are the options here? He doesn't KNOW what kind of dog it was, so are we to assume he means a dog that is:

- invisible and weigthless?
- exact clone of a leash?
- already dead, so he's pointing out to the dog's spirit/ghost we can't see?
- completely bodiless?
- the 'joke dog' Alan bought from Las Vegas in one of the 'Two and Half Men' episodes, that consists of a 'stiff, but wobbly leash you can move to make it look like you are walking an invisible dog' (and doing even that wrong by letting it in front of you)

What kind of sense does it make for the cop to say 'like THIS'?

Sure, he had some kind of dog as a kid that he liked to call 'pooch', thus never understanding the dog psychology, so the dog would probably HAVE been better off dead, but 'like this'??

What does 'this' refer to, exactly? To the mangled carcass miles away in the bushes where no one can see it? To little pieces of a dog body?

Did the cop follow them for long enough to actually have seen the dog, and why refer to the dog as 'this' instead of 'that', since the DOG IS NOT HERE WITH US (from his perspective)?

There are moments in movies that keep bothering me more and more until I can't take it anymore, and this is one of them. 'Pooch like this'? No.

'A dog I treated badly because I did not understand rules, boundaries, limitations - or exercize, discipline, affection. I just treated it as a 'pooch' instead of animal-dog, so I never fulfilled its psychological needs'? Yes.

So what the heck is going on here? Is the cop on LSD and is seeing floating dogs all over the place?

Is the cop so emotional about it, he actually sees a dog when holding the leash?

Is there a photo of the dog on the leash?

Is..

You get the idea.

This scene makes NO sense whatsoever!

I hate when even the most classic, great movies have to have a scene that makes zero sense. Sigh.

reply


Still waiting for your "B-17 piston engine bomber sounds from a jet on Airplane! makes no sense"....

reply


And I know I shouldn't answer your desperate, obvious, and grasps for attention, but the cop SAW with his own eyes the dog on the leash and the carcass on the road. The cop doesn't have a Star Trek transporter (which you've already told us doesn't make sense), so when the cop saw the dog behind the Wagon Queen Family Truckster, he couldn't magically materialize directly behind Clark to pull him over.

Sigh..

reply

The cop tells Clark he is going to go "retrieve the carcass". So most likely he already saw the dog's mangled body before he pulled Clark over. Maybe the carcass was in such a condition he was able to see a similarity to the dog he once had.

reply

BEWARE! Avortac4 is a troll trying to waste everyone's time with such idiotic comments. Look at his posts. He doesn't think anything in any film makes sense. His post may seem like it makes sense in the first sentence or two. But he always quickly wanders off into a completely idiotic idea, and then writes a wall of text that makes no sense. And his sole purpose is to waste your time, thinking he's cute for doing so. Don't feed the troll. If you write a comment, you're giving this troll EXACTLY what he wants. Don't comment after my comment.

reply

How long have you suspected this about Avortac4?

reply

OP needs an intervention. The hallucinogenic substances have compromised his brain.

reply