Thoughts On Cully?


What are your thoughts on the character Cully?

reply

I didn't find her a particularly interesting character, she was okay, but not outstanding. that episode where she has a reunion with her three old schoolfriends I found very strange - why hasn't she seen any of them for ten years? None of them seem to live fery far away, and she comes home frequently, so why hasn't she been in regular touch with them? It makes no sense,

reply

I didn't like that episode simply due to Cully being so pushy about it all..but its not uncommon to not be in touch with friends that live close by. I have friends that live within 15 minutes of me I have not seen or talked to in years, and often think..one day I am going to catch up with them. I also recently got in touch with an old friend and found out he lives in the next suburb to me and has done so for 20 years, but not once have we run into each other. Things like that do happen.

reply

Well, it doesn't seem very believable to me. if you really like someone, you keep in touch. At least by phone or email, even if you don't meet often.

reply

It's very believable. Adults tend to drift away from one another due to work and, if they are married a partner keeping one person from seeing his/her old friends. My ex made sure I never saw my friends, but insisted we socialize with hers. That is what happens when you have a controlling partner, but friends I considered dear once I have not seen over twice in 3 decades and we all still live in the same are. Life happens, and email is a fairly recent thing so we did not have it, and you play phone tag with people. People grow up and drift away

reply

[deleted]

but cully isn't marriedl, and these are supposed to have been her best friends at school. i don't find it at all believable that she would suddenly, after ten years, want a reunion wth three girls she'd never bothered to contact in the intervening time, when none of them live very far from her. emails have been around for a long time now, and the telephone even longer, and letter post even longer than that. for that matter, why couldn't she drop in on them? This is the very small county of Midsomer, not some vast American state. I just don't understand why anyone would bother to try and arrange a reunion with three girls she hadn't cared to see or speak to for ten years.

reply

I have to agree with you. It seems strange that Cully would have absolutely no contact with her three best friends from school, and yet these three would be "as thick as thieves" with each other the entire time. That could explain the lukewarm response to the reunion. It would not have been a reunion for the other three, since they are in constant contact with each other. But here is another point. I would not do what Cully did even with people I see constantly. I would never make a reservation, and then tell my friends. Before I did that, I would contact them to pick a restaurant we all liked, and to make a date when we could all attend.

reply

she came across as someone who didn't really have any friends even in adult life. so clinging onto friends that she used to have even if they were once her tormentors could make sense that way

reply

But she hadn't clung onto them, that's the odd thing. She hadn't had anything to do with them for ten years. that's what makes the whole thing really strange.

reply

she didn't have to cling onto them through 10 years but cling to the idea of them having been good friends to want a reunion

reply

I thought the reunion episode was a little odd, in that Cully's ex-chums seemed closer to one another than any of them were to Cully. There was a passing reference to Cully having been bullied by at least one of them. Perhaps Cully had a rose-tinted view of her school days, while the others thought of her as the twerp they used to pick on, if they thought of her at all?

reply

Yeah I felt that too, I felt sorry for Cully in that episode. I kind of got the feeling they were all friends and Cully was the odd one out, even though she was the one pushing the reunion, it was like they couldn't be bothered with her.

I didn't get whey the fat girl was holding Cully under the water, I know they were having a laugh, but it seemed more sinister they way she was holding her under.

reply

Joyce makes that very point when Cully mentions wanting to get together with her old friends. She said isn't that the girl (blonde one) who always mean to you? Then Cully goes on to say oh she was just playfully teasing me.
We really got to see the truth when the three almost drown Cully and after what the blonde said to her when she tried killing her. Cully was in lala land in that one.

reply

cully was an idiot. they tried to drown her for fun and she still insisted they were friends and it was fine

reply

I find it very believable to not see friends who live close by. People change and sometimes grow apart. I've been in a similar situation where I hadn't seen a friend in years. When I did finally get together with them, it wasn't the same, we had nothing in common, except our past.

reply

But Cully doesn't act like that, she acts like someone who's all enthusiasm for the reunion. If she felt that keen on them, you'd think she'd at least have phoned them, or emailed them or something over the years.

reply

I got the feeling she was just feeling nostalgic one day and remember the pact they all made to get together in 10 years. None of the others even remembered the pact.

reply

well, they didn't really need to, because they'd been seeing each other in the interim.

reply

I thought that too as I've only just watched that ep for the first time. Also, is she a wannabe actress that constantly pops 'round her parents' house? Or is she just an annoying, ageless extra with speaking lines that just gets in the way? I veer towards the latter, her fat-tongue, non-lisp, and emotionless face make me miss dialogue sometimes as I'm stressing over what emotion she's supposed to be showing?
The angles that she is shot at don't help, but she and her mother should take a long cruise together, maybe 4 seasons worth?

reply

I think a couple of things came out in this episode that help to explain why Cully's "reunion" went so sour. From things Joyce said when Cully was talking about planning the get-together, it seemed pretty obvious that Cully was NEVER really a friend to any of these people. They bullied her, Joyce indicated, but Cully has rose-tinted nostalgic glasses on and makes excuses. The fact that neither Joyce nor Tom had any really sharp memories of these friends of their daughter was another tip-off that Cully is trying to create a relationship where no real closeness ever existed beyond the way the three others sort of used her back in the day. (And the "playful" dunking scene at the picnic made it clear that not much had changed.) I have to say that I really wanted to shake some sense into Cully all through this episode - WHY did she persist in trying to be bosom buddies with these people who never had any real respect for her to begin with? For someone who attended Cambridge University, Cully can be awfully dense at times, and in this episode, she is like a piece of petrified wood!

reply

I liked that she got married. I mean, I know she is just a character on a show, but she left the show and when I watched later episodes I felt sort of comforted to think of her off with her husband, instead of alone somewhere. It was a good call by the producers/writers/whomever. And to be honest, once she was with Simon (that was his name, no?) she seemed more real and to have more depth.


Donna -Ta da!

reply

Nico, wasn't that Cully's boyfriend's name? I'm new to the series. Binge watching on Netflix so I might be behind, but that's who she hooked up with early on. He even temporarily moved in with her and parents for a time.

reply

Yes, Nico was the name of one of Cully's earlier boyfriends. In the books, Nico is the one she married. In the TV series, however, she married Simon.

reply

Simon. I haven't watched far enough to meet Simon. Thanks for the head's up.

reply

she was meh. also, i'd like to know what her real name is, i doubt it's as stupid as cully


reply

Her real name is Laura Howard.

reply

the character's name, not the actress


reply

Silly me lol.

reply

In “The Killings at Badger’s Drift,” the first show of the Midsomer series, Barnaby refers to her in passing as Catherine Lacy.

P.S. In general, I found Cully’s appearances to be annoying. Cully hanging around in Causton did little to nothing to move the story along; she seemed to spend more time at home than she did at uni in Cambridge. The novels Caroline Graham wrote depicted Barnaby as a man who enjoyed his family and preferred to be with them over anything else. I guess they wanted to continue this theme for the show, but for me, a young woman claiming to be independent while returning home nearly every weekend for the thinnest of excuses just seemed forced and unnecessary.


 Some movies are released; others sneak out. 

reply

CineVerite wrote:
"in “The Killings at Badger’s Drift,” the first show of the Midsomer series, Barnaby refers to her in passing as Catherine Lacy. "

Katherine Lacey was the murderer, played by Emily Mortimer. So I do not really know what you mean?

reply

According to J ohn nettles, cully is named after a village in Switzerland where the Barnabys were staying when their daughter wAs conceived. Suppose it might have been worse. They could have been staying in llanfIrpwllgwyngyll for instance.

reply

seriously? oh dear. but you're right, it could have been worse

reply

My former boss named her child after a city in Australia where she had previously vacationed.

reply

In King's Crystal, she is very annoyed that her father suddenly left in the middle of her performance in a Shakespeare play. She was so annoyed that she yelled at her father and then stomped out of the house. Now Cully can do some very annoying things but I have never seen her yell at her father. That is so out of character. Also, I'm wondering why they put the play on in that cramped amphitheater when there is a perfectly good traditional theater in downtown Causton. And also wouldn't Barnaby always sit at the end of a row so he could make a quick exit if he had to?

reply

lawson,I agree about Cully's rudeness. Also, for someone playing an actress she was dreadful as Ophelia-spoken as former professional actress,director & student of Shakespeare-really surprised me. I had to quit due to disability before I get remarks.

reply

As a current professional actor, director and producer, I found Laura Howard's performance of Cully's Ophelia to be sublime. She's not supposed to be a Shakespearean savant. She's a young struggling actor and Howard portrayed this perfectly.

reply

[deleted]

I realize that I'm "replying" to a comment that's over a year old, but that's because for some reason, IMDb's platform doesn't allow users to just add new comments to a thread.

Anyway, I share the majority view that Cully is annoying, for many of the reasons given. I'm not particularly fond of her mother, either.

I found the "Hamlet" scene in "King's Crystal" flawed in a couple of ways.

First of all, twentysomething Cully seems a bit too old to be so anxious about whether her parents, especially Daddy, would show up at her performance.

This may be deliberate, because her character is supposed to be a somewhat spoiled, or indulged, only child-- but she behaves more like an adolescent girl in her first "important" school play.

Still, I also disliked the very contrived business of having the elder Barnabys make a conspicuous entrance, then having Tom make an even more conspicuous, even disruptive, exit precisely as Cully is in the middle of a climactic scene.

Yes, yes, the modern police/mystery genre's universal prime cliché is that police officers are torn between their professional obligations and family life.

This, in turn, spawns endless sub-clichés: depending on how dark and "gritty" the series is written, the star's family life is a constant struggle, or outright disaster because of the incurable conflict between work and family. This occurs because the star cop is always so fanatically devoted to his work that they are compelled to put their work over their family life.

The problem with this overarching cliché is that it's been done to death-- and, as in this case, can be heavy-handed to the point of ridiculous.

Here, they didn't bother to even try and make it more plausible-- by, say, Barnaby being called away because of some real emergency.

Put another way, under the circumstances even a dedicated police officer would at least wait until his daughter's moment of glory was over before dashing off.

It's not as if Barnaby's tactless exit was a matter of life or death; in fact, the series makes a point of the bodies piling up while Barnaby's on the case.

As preposterous as that contrived scene was, since-- unlike Barnaby-- I had to sit through it, I hoped for a better payoff afterwards. Instead, when Cully finally sees her delinquent dad afterwards, Barnaby just mutters a reflexive "sorry" for probably the hundred thousandth time.

Back to the topic: I never miss Cully when she's not there, but that's because of the way her character is written, not Laura Howard's acting. Speaking of which-- since I've never seen her in any other role, I've always wondered if her patented annoying frowny-face expression is good acting, or an unfortunate carry-over from real life.

reply

The character's real name is Cully. Her first name is taken from a village on Lake Geneva in Switzerland, where she was conceived during her parents' honeymoon.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cully,_Switzerland

reply

[deleted]

i despise Cully - she is sarcastic, condescending, self-centered, and snotty. besides being pretty, i can't think of a single positive quality.

have you tried that crazy wrap thing?! http://erinleighmckenzie.myitworks.com

reply

Cully seemed nice enough but all things considered, we didn't really get to know her all that well. We knew she had gone to University and auditioned for a play whilst there, got the part and then decided to change her course by becoming an actress. The thing that annoyed me was how quickly the relationship between her and Simon developed. Okay, I get that you have to have a suspension of belief when watching a show but it felt like no sooner we were introduced to him they were getting engaged and getting married, it all felt a little rushed.

There was the whole will they/won't they between her and Gavin, then when DS Scott joined people were thinking maybe they'd get together. I think the writers just ended up not knowing what to do with her so brought someone in so she could get married and set off from the nest. Her coming back all the time, doing different jobs each time, it felt like rinse and repeat a bit.

Cully felt rinse and repeat in the end. Going for auditons,thinking she wouldn't get them then she did, coming home and doing different jobs, will they/won't they romances, Cully getting annoyed at how little she saw her dad because of his work etc etc.

The writers could have been brave and killed her off, it would've been interesting to see how the Barnaby's would've coped with that and whether their marriage would have survived or not. Alas, it didn't happen!

reply

i think they probably decided to marry her off because it was a good way to reduce her appearances, her being busy with her husband. i would have hated it if they had killed her off, that would have blighted the barnabys lives forever. they would never get over losing their only child. it would have been horrible.

reply

[deleted]

I suppose it wasn't a particularly interesting role to play. she seems to have done some TV since then, parts in Casualty, eastenders etc, and also theatre. she was in the Norman Conquests at the Liverpool Playhouse a few years ago. I don't know what part she played, probably Annie I would guess, but at any rate a more interesting role rhan Cully.

reply

[deleted]

Cully is a spoiled brat, a gossip and finks on everyone. She is not happy unless she gets her way and always gets in the way when her father has to question one of her friends in an investigation because "I like him".

Joyce is very spoiled as well but at least she contributes sometimes when Barnaby is investigating cases.

As for Barnaby, he is in charge of investigations and the girls are the bosses at home






Too bad bitching doesn't burn calories

reply

I became very fond of Tom's family, including Cully, and of Troy too. Tom's was a happy family and that was good to see, they were all good, intelligent people, strong characters, yet not about to get pushed around by anyone either. There were so many other interesting and complex characters, it really made the show a fine one.

When you get up in the morning, how do you decide what shade of black to wear? (Shallow Grave)

reply

[deleted]

Loads of Joyce bashing too and I think her character is a lovely person and quite funny with her cooking efforts, health kicks, and other projects. They make a great family. *Sigh* It must be jealousy.

When you get up in the morning, how do you decide what shade of black to wear? (Shallow Grave)

reply

[deleted]

I felt Tom's family was the normalcy of the series. He'd go off and solve crimes committed by homicidal maniacs, but could always come home to Joyce and Cully to recharge his batteries. They were village people. Connected to the community. They always knew people in the towns where grizzly murders occurred. The balance added humor to the show.

reply

I thought Cully was the weakest character of the regulars, as if the writers didn't know what to do with her. Tom and Joyce got great play off each other, but Cully always seemed on the outside.

reply

I thought Cully was the weakest character of the regulars, as if the writers didn't know what to do with her. Tom and Joyce got great play off each other, but Cully always seemed on the outside.


Funny, I feel completely the opposite. I think Tom and Joyce have ZERO chemistry. He just seems to tolerate her, and she seems oblivious to him. Tom and Cully seem to have a nice rapport, though.

reply