What a shame


To start with I believe that Kubrik's film version is disturbing and haunting but lacking in the overall character commitment to the novel. Kubrik's focused on Torrance and the eerie intact of the Overlook without being clear as to the how or why of the impact it had on Torrance. King was correct that Kubrik didn't grasp the supernatural well, but I think that makes him wise to avoid that plot line then.

Here is the criminal thing... King wanted a different version and set out to make it, then out popped this turd. A Stephen King novel turned into made for TV cannot succeed to the depths it needs to. To properly set up the suspense it needs to be dark, morose, graphic and all things a rated R movie brings that TV cannot.

The characters were more true to the book, especially Grady. But the acting was poor, especially by the kid and Melvin Van Peebles. That would be ok if it wasn't a cast of 3 plus side characters... And what was missing was understanding the reasons behind the outrageous character actions, Derwent, Ullman, Al...all these side characters help explain the depth of Jack's character struggle. Too bad really.

reply

I've seen both films and read the novel.

The Kubrick version was actually a pretty shallow movie, totally lacking the depth and meaning of the novel, and it was a pretty useless representation of this King story. And I don't blame King for taking issue with Kubrick's lack of humanity, like O'Halloran making the trip all the way to the hotel just to be murdered when he arrived, which is not what happened in the novel. What point was Kubrick trying to make with his version of this?

The miniseries was pretty close to the novel, but you're right, the graphicness of the novel was sacrificed a little from the TV censors -- like in the novel, Jack's rampage with the mallet was even more violent than what we saw in the miniseries, and Wendy's injuries from it were more severe.

And other things from the novel that could've been put in the miniseries, like the big clock spurting blood, and other interesting things like Danny having a vision of something resembling an octopus flying through the air, which was actually the magneto from the snowmobile, that Jack threw across the yard after he sabotaged the vehicle.

But King's story here was not just about horror, it was also about redemption, which was totally lost on Kubrick, which is not surprising considering the very cold filmmaker he always was.

reply

Kubrick's The Shining just went DIRECTLY over your head... To even compare this miniseries to the actual film is laughable. Hallorans death has a very DEEP meaning.If you missed it, you missed the other 2hrs as well

reply

Ten do tell what is its meaning?

reply