MovieChat Forums > The Cider House Rules (2000) Discussion > This is certainly one of the best films ...

This is certainly one of the best films of all time.

posted 16 years ago by turningleaf2
10 replies | jump to latest

I have watched this film over and over again and have also read the book, which delves more into the moral dilema of the characters. It is beautifully acted, beautifully written and has an incredible score. The only flaw I can find with the film is the "what is your business?" bit. I believe this should be in the top 250 and certainly deserves more than a 7.4 rating. I have seen almost every film in the top 250, and there are very few that can compare to this.To me, only Stand By Me captures the feeling of innocence this film does.

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] MiqeaPA 16 years ago

I agree too. I've seen this about hundreds of times. And I dont get tired of it.

[–] bluesguy 16 years ago

Running On Empty with River Phoenix and Judd Hirsch (sp) and others falls into your catagory. Great movie if you have not watched it.

[–] BoxOfficeKid 16 years ago

I agree, definetaly among imdb top 250

[–] nameless_joe1500 16 years ago

I saw it yesterday for the first time, but i missed the beginning. I have a question for you all. Was Homer retarded?

[–] wozley 16 years ago

No. You should watch it again. If that's still a pressing question, maybe this isn't your type of movie.

He's a very smart person with very little exposure to the world beyond the orphanage. His choices are naive, but well-intentioned.

[–] jkpauley-1 16 years ago

This film is warped and so are you.

[–] DaDudeAbides 15 years ago

I loved the book, but wasn't a big fan of the movie.... I would say it's a little above average. I was able to fill in some of the gaps the movie left out, but I just didn't see the movie doing a good job of building the characters and making you care about them. The movie makes Candy into a slut, "I'm no good at being alone." You never get to see why Larch is so pro-choice, which is why I think "pro-life" people are so against this movie. "What is your business" was a part of the book as well, it emphasized how Mr. Rose was able to control the workers so well. I'm glad you enjoyed the movie so much, maybe if I rewatch in a year or so I'll be able to appreciate the movie more.

Yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man. - The Dude

[–] GrammarMatters 15 years ago

I love this movie. It is in my top 100 movies (and I've seen way too many movies.)

I'm watching it in High Def right now, and I've seen it maybe about 6 times, and it makes me cry more each time I see it.

Gosh, Charlez is so beautiful. Her and Toby's acting is so great. I definitely think this movie is worth more than a 7.4 rating. I think the pro-life people talk this movie down.

[–] suman_austin 15 years ago

I definitely agree. This movie deserved a rating more than 8. It was one of the movies in which the casting was absolutely spot-on.

Every Movie is not for Everybody.