MovieChat Forums > Fight Club (1999) Discussion > What kind of person likes this movie? Wh...

What kind of person likes this movie? Why did you like it?


Do you have to be an angry person to like this movie? A person mad at the world and the politics and society and their injustice? Or maybe you just have to like people beating each other? What are the reasons people like this movie?



Btw, I love it myself. It's one of my favourite movies if not my favourite movie of all times. But I'm interested in knowing what others find good about it.

reply

I think the film resonates with generation X, Y probably milennials too who are sort of disillusioned with a materialist, consumer society.

To be honest, these days the film even has more of an impact considering all the recent terror atrocities and extremism rising up all over the world.

Some people actually look up to Tyler Durden though. I thought the concept was cool when the film came out. As I matured I saw the film more as it is meant to be, a critique and exposition of both of consumer society and extremism.

But that is the brilliance of the film, it makes you root for something you're not meant to root for. I still consider this film the masterpiece of the 90s.

reply

I love this movie, but I see it in a very different light from most people. I feel like a lot of people (the majority of them being male) take this movie seriously and legitimately look up to Tyler as a role model to be followed. Which is genuinely terrifying to think about.

I feel like this movie wasn't meant to be taken seriously, though. I see it as a parody of masculinity that pokes fun at the toxic ways some men express their frustration with modern society and their feelings of parental abandonment, not feeling special, frustration with consumerism/mass culture, etc. You could probably make an argument against my interpretation of the film, but I think the book was certainly intended to be a parody, especially after having read some of the author's other work, which includes similar themes.

reply

I say this is parody bordering on reality.

However, I don't think it necessarily is some parody of masculinity. It is truthful in fact. A part of masculinity will always be violence, or simulated violence and figthing no matter what context. You find this among extreme-right and also extreme-left, and dead-centre politics as find it in boxing, martial arts and other walks of life. Men want to fight other men, struggle and have a purpose. It is consumerism society that replaces this struggle with sofas; and the fight with support groups. This is bound to frustrate young, angry men and drive them underground.

This is isn't 'toxic masculinity' however, as I see you imply. Its more a flaw with a materialist consumer society lacking values and ideals for men. Tyler Durden exploits this and turns this group into an increasingly violent terrorist organisation. Not alltogether unrealistic. If you look at many extreme Islamist groups today for instance, their rhetoric is aimed almost purely against Western influence and materialism.

reply

I'm a woman born in the 70s, not sure what my generation title is (LOL) but I love this movie for a specific reason. I was recovering from surgery for cancer when I first saw this and there were many scene that spoke to me, made me look at myself, and got me out of a depressing circle I was in at the time. The one line "it's only when we've lost everything that we're free to do anything" was awake up call. Just my opinion.

reply

I'm currently 27 and saw Fight Club when I was 17. I watch it at least once or twice a year, sometimes more. On the surface, I love the film because it is gritty, darkly hilarious, visually stunning and endlessly entertaining. Story-wise, I love stories about people who reject societal norms, explore or channel their primal impulses, along with stories about men discovering or re-claiming their masculinity in some way. Fight Club, as a story, does all of those things and is a great exploration and satire of male psychology.

The film and book hold up very well, giving us an inside look at the psychology of angry young men who feel insignificant or emasculated and want to make a stand, in this case causing destruction, to break the mold. With the number of violent rampages or attacks that make the news regularly, the story is still relevant in that regard.




My latest movie: Available internationally here!
https://vimeo.com/ondemand/primordial

reply

I feel like I watch it to keep myself from going crazy. The movie is so insane and gets more and more wacko as it goes on that it actually keeps me from becoming disillusioned by this filthy world. A movie about insanity gives me my sanity, if that makes sense.

reply

That makes perfect sense to me. Music, movies and books about insanity have brought me a lot of catharsis through the years.





My latest movie: Available internationally here!
https://vimeo.com/ondemand/primordial

reply

Yeah, I agree. Fight Club is my therapy.

I watch it once a month, getting great comfort from it. It's my main reference point. It helps to ground me in reality, knowing that the job I do within this corporatist market economy is POINTLESS. I feel bad and frustrated, not because there's something wrong with me, but because there's something wrong with this crazy mixed up world.

I can relate to Fight Club because it speaks the truth.

reply

I sometimes feel like a nihilist. A wanna-be anarchist. I definitely have been spending a lot time pondering just how empty of a void we live in. I don't believe that existence has any inherent value in of itself, but we can create or add whatever value to it we want. Make something of this life, I keep telling myself. That's what I get from Fight Club. Accept and know, not fear, know that one day you are going to die. And there's no coming back. Nothing else after this. No afterlife. All we have is now. Do something with it. Do what you want. Believe what you will, I just choose to not subscribe to a God that I have no proof exists.

reply

I like it because it's clever; it does an excellent job of telling the origin story of a villain and making everyone think it's a hero's journey.

To be clear: Were Tyler Durden/the Narrator a main character in any story except his own, he'd be a villain. He's a cult leader and a domestic terrorist and also batshyte crazy. He's built up a cult of personality among his nameless followers ("In project Mayhem, we have no names") that's so strong they follow his every command without question. He wants to destroy society, which is the goal of most anarchist villains in most movies. (Consider the Joker from Dark Knight).

However, we're not watching this from the perspective of an outsider horrified at Durden's actions, seeing his impassioned speeches and wanton destruction for the insanity that it is. We're watching from inside Durden's head, and villains are always heroes in their own mind. Thus he is a savior, an enlightened leader, a rebel with a noble cause of freeing people from the trappings of society. He alone knows the Truth, and is attempting to lead his followers into a brave new world. He just has to destroy the old world first.

Isn't that the gist of what most evil cult leaders have planned in movies like this? Of course it is. But is sounds so much more reasonable and enticing when you're part of the cult.

In fact is sounds so enticing that at the end, when even the Narrator realizes Durden is a villain and does his best to stop him, a large chunk of the audience still refuse to acknowledge him as anything other than a misguided hero.

It was a clever way to tell the story, and I was impressed.

When there's no more room on the internet, the dumb will walk the earth.

reply

What kind of person likes this movie?


Short Answer: Someone with good taste.

Don't Click This I dare You >>> https://youtu.be/zbJjvt6bbQ8👊

reply

I like it because it's anti-bourgeois. Someone I know thought that the message of the film was that people should do dangerous things and take risks. I think the message is that if people don't find socially acceptable, constructive ways of making their lives authentic, then their unconscious is liable to take over and use socially unacceptable, destructive ways to find authenticity.

reply

I like movies to challenge me and make me think, usually my first reaction is that I need to see it again as soon as possible. This was one such.

Sometimes films can be too overwhelming like "Seven" loved it, brilliant performances but unsure I ever want to see it again.

reply