MovieChat Forums > Charmed (1998) Discussion > Does the general public 1st think of Pho...

Does the general public 1st think of Phoebe-Piper-Paige as the Charmed Ones


Instead of Prue-Phoebe-Piper? Maybe this has to due with the fact that Rose McGowan was on the show longer than Shannen Doherty. To make matters worse, the producers once Shannen was off the show, couldn't show footage or images of Prue since I believe Shannen denied them permission (if she didn't get a hefty payday). This is why it took much longer for the first three seasons to be released on DVD.

reply

The few people who care certainly consider the original Halliwell sisters to be the Charmed ones, regardless of which cast it is. The "new" sisters are nothing but a cheap knock-off and a way for CW to virtue signal to anyone stupid enough to watch their crap shows.

reply

Not sure so many agree with Prue over Paige. Paige was on the show a bit longer.

reply

The knock off is terrible, non stop political agenda and the actresses playing the "sisters" are different races! At least the original 3 actresses and for that matter Paige as well looked like they may have been related.

reply

Yeah, I remember that a clear way to tell someone was a Halliwell was 2 features: brunette, and they had a name that started with the letter "P."

reply

I preferred Prue over Paige. It sucks that Doherty and Milano couldn't get along.

reply

NO. The original sisters are the real charmed sisters. the show tanked after brenda left.

reply

Agreed.

reply