MovieChat Forums > Rear Window (1998) Discussion > Which is better? The remake or the origi...

Which is better? The remake or the original one?


Hey,
There's a competition and I'd like to ask for your help. I have to write a long /6 pages!/essay comparing Hitchcock's original movie and this version of Rear window. What do you think about the remake? Which version do you prefer? Why?
I'm really interested in all the opinions and ideas. Thanks in advance!

reply



Watch them and find out.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

mrpacket, you have superb style :)

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

This is like asking who was the better Bond, Connery or Timothy Dalton...

reply

Dalton. No Question.

@deflemonkid

reply

Sorry I got here late... looks like you got a lot of help from the idiot data movie base faithful. I would have told you to set up two televisions and go scene by scene... have a note pad that denotes lighting, plot, scenery, pacing and over all feel and then look at other movies that both directors shot and note difference and the overall success of the films and the directors.

The truth is, Spielberg and Dustin Hoffman wouldn't have worked together on this project... Chris Reeves had no choice and I was glad for one to see him a last time.

How did the paper go?

reply

Well aren't you a regular king arthur, galloping up to save the day... let the kid do his own godamn assignment. I used to have to write my essays with coal and goats-blood while walking through the snow barefoot.

reply