MovieChat Forums > Adaptation. (2003) Discussion > Maybe it's me...I didn't get it

Maybe it's me...I didn't get it


Maybe I was watching it while half-asleep on Netflix, but I found that the whole scenario with Meryl suggesting to kill Charlie came out of left field. I felt like I was watching a totally different movie.

Spoiler alert upcoming:




I didn't like the fact that they allowed Donald to die. It was like I was watching a movie about a novel, which is supposed to be kind of predictable and boring, and then I jumped into an action movie with a normal human being turned psycho killer. I guess I didn't appreciate that. If I wanted a movie with killing I'd have watched Con Air of Face Off!

That's not saying I didn't find the movie good; I just felt it was not what I expected it to be and was kind of disappointed in the overall plot change and ending.



This is my signature and I'm sticking to it. lol

reply

The whole point of the change in plot structure toward the end was because Donald got involved in the writing of Charlie's screenplay. As soon as that happened, and Robert McKee came in as the deus ex machina, the movie began going in the direction Charlie didn't want his adaptation to go. Donald was all about cliches and shallow action, and before you know it the movie itself becomes a culmination of these cliches.

This movie's entirely about the exploration of the process of screenwriting, even within the plot itself, acting as metafiction. Charlie Kaufman (who's really the screenwriter of Adaptation) came up with the idea for this movie because he was struggling adapting The Orchid Thief. Donald, Charlie's inner voice telling him to make *beep* up and Hollywoodize it so it would be exciting, became a character in the movie that had to be killed off, ultimately.

reply

Jobeykobra is exactly right. Charlie brings Donald in to help him with the script and suddenly (and nonsensically) we have mystery, guns, car chases and heroic but silly deaths.

_____________________________
"Knowing how the world works
Is not knowing how to work the world"

reply

I hadn't thought about Robert as a deus ex machina. I thought the deus ex machina was supposed to be represented by the alligator, but now that you said it, you are right. It was pretty obvious actually. Don't know how I didn't catch this when I saw it (maybe because I've only seen it once, but that should've been enough to get something that obvious).

reply

At the same time it's sort of defending Donald's way of writing because the ending isn't all that bad and Charlie's big resolution in the third acting is actually a nice sentiment. It all gets tied up in a bow, which he didn't want, so in a sense he's giving Hollywood the ending they want the best way you can, but admitting that he knows it's Cliche.

reply

I got it but it's too bad it wasn't worth getting.

reply