MovieChat Forums > The Wire (2002) Discussion > Who didn't you like as an actor..,?

Who didn't you like as an actor..,?


For me, rawles

I like him as an actor...but think he's weak in this.

reply

Couldn't disagree more...

reply

I don't think any of the regular actors are bad at all, but there are a few weaker links if you look close enough.

Here's an insightful bit from Kent Jones on the various actors of the show. I agree with him that some actors, like Reddick and especially Turman and Sohn, are a little one-dimensional compared to the best of the cast:

"Most of the acting on The Wire is unusually good, though there's a broad spectrum of talent, style and creative intelligence. Dominic West is a little too sunny for the maniacally obsessive detective he's playing, but his ebullience makes a good fit with McNulty's contrite side and with his cockiness. Aidan Gillen leans into the voracious politician Tommy Carcetti like a mariner heading into a gale, an all-forward-movement performance, while Clarke Peters' detective Lester Freamon is a sedentary piece of winningly hambone stoicism. Clark Johnson does some nicely textured work as the Sun's city editor, injecting little bursts of invective into his character's relaxed surface, while Wendell Pierce's detective Bunk is the kind of authoritative character performance one used to see on a routine basis from Vincent Gardenia or Yaphet Kotto. Sometimes the actors enliven the characters, as with Seth Gilliam as the street cop Carver, a fascinating actor who shifts between states of tension and occasionally swan-dives into soliloquies of paternalistic authority before the corner kids, or Amy Ryan, who shades an unusual amount of emotion into her quietly grounded port cop. Sometimes the writing carries the actor, as with Glynn Turman, who heaps too much bullsh-t all over his Mayor Royce, or Sonja Sohn as detective Kima Greggs, a genuinely monotonous actor who tries to make her limited repertoire of head-bobbing exasperation and hip-hugging indignation suit every situation.

Each of these characters would be fodder for a superior cop show, but they become truly interesting when placed within The Wire's vast social web and in the context of the depiction of police work as blue-collar drudgery - one episode ends with an entire investigative unit racing to type up a mountain of paperwork in order to meet a deadline for a search warrant. Only John Doman's 'Deputy Ops' Bill Rawls, Robert Wisdom's Major Bunny Colvin and Al Brown's Stan Valchek stand out as wholly original creations. Lance Reddick's Lieutenant Cedric Daniels is also quite captivating, a striver with a couple of skeletons in his closet who rises to the top on the strength of his police work alone. Reddick's effort to maintain a stiff-backed dignity can be very touching but I wish he had a few more arrows in his quiver: every other word comes out with a whoosh, as if shot from a catapult.
"

http://old.bfi.org.uk/sightandsound/feature/49447

reply

"Reddick's effort to maintain a stiff-backed dignity can be very touching but I wish he had a few more arrows in his quiver: every other word comes out with a whoosh, as if shot from a catapult."



She was hardly a regular but the actress who plays Alma was pretty bad.

reply

none, the acting is flawless.

reply

Probably Marlo.

The actor had only one expression throughout. I know he was supposed to be a kind of "cipher" of a guy. Slacked jawed staring usually isn't acting.

But we needed more behind the eyes. More depth from expression to convey a lot non-verbally the way the best actors can do with just a facial muscle or look in the eye.

Look at the master Dominic West, for one. He could do more with 10 seconds of closeup with no dialogue than "Marlo" could with a page of script.

He was too weak an actor I think for a role that was SO pivotal.

He was like a blank slate to me from beginning to end. The actor never conveyed enough to make me believe he was that powerful or smart, even with his violent killing team to do the heavy lifting while he watched.

Good actors let you see the wheels turning in the character's head. That never happened for me with Marlo.

reply

I could not stand the actor/character Bubbles. Could not put my finger on why. He's another character on the Show Empire and I still can't stand him.

reply

He's the best thing about Empire other than the leads.

reply

Three actors who kind of irked me and why:
Frankie Faison as Commissioner Burrell - too wooden, pauses at unnatural, irregular moments in speech; felt like he was focusing too much on reciting his lines.
Anwar Grover as Slim Charles - good character, wrong actor to play it. Like Burrell, too wooden in delivery.
Isiah Whitlock Jr. as Clay Davis - histrionic overacting, much in the Jack Nicholson vein.
Other actors who had ups & downs were Sonja Sohn as Kima Greggs (some of the more "up close & personal" scenes with her are not very believable) and Lance Reddick as Cedric Daniels.
My take!

reply

I agree with a few and disagree with a few of you guys. But blame can be laid at the writers feet with some.

I like bubbles /Andre on the hellboy dudes show. Hand of God. Marlo on Bosch is kinda in the same vein as Marlo on the wire.

reply

Lmao @ your comment about Burrell. It always looked like he was thinking "What the hell am I supposed to say next?"

As for Slim Charles his character was believable for me because I know someone that acts just like him. Just a very serious dude that rarely ever smiles or laughs.

Clay Davis- if I hear Sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeiiiiiiiiiiit one more time!!!!

Kima- just got on my damn nerves

Herc- reminds me of a cop I know here in Brooklyn

Cedric Daniels was THE MOST stiff actor on the show, from his delivery of lines to the way he walked. He was a human stick figure.

If you also share my love of arts&crafts, please check out my YouTube channel@ https://goo.gl/3XrsKF

reply

[deleted]

This thread is hilarious. People complaining about characters thinking they're complaining about acting.

reply

What's hilarious is your uppity attitude. I didn't like those characters or the acting of those that portrayed those characters.
If you also share my love of arts&crafts, please check out my YouTube channel@ https://goo.gl/3XrsKF

reply

awww sh!t... I'm an uppity negro now...lol... Seriously though people complaining about the actor that played Ervin Burrell is laughable. The man has over 100 acting credits. Starting acting in Shakespeare plays with James Earl Jones, he's done comedy, horror, drama, Marvel, he's done it all. Acting is second nature to him.

Yet you're questioning this man acting ability is what is laughable. The reason he always looked like he was thinking "What the hell am I supposed to say next?" is cause he was portraying a man that was failing at his job. What is he supposed seem confident?

The point is most people are complaining about character traits and actions, not the actual portrayal of the character in the way they fit into the story. If you're not doing that then why even get offended?

reply

I think everyone was great, although I could tell snoop and slim Charles weren't professional actors, I still loved them in it.

reply

Dominic West is the reason I rate this show a 9/10 instead of a 10. He's never impressed me in any of the ten or so projects I've seen him in, even UK ones where his mediocre US accent isn't an impediment. Despite that I still rank it as the best TV drama I've seen.

reply