The rating is too low


This movie deserves a higher rating than 7,4 - it's one of those movies that you can watch over and over again, matures like fine wine. The acting is really excellent, each actor delivers a believable and authentic performance and Russell is simply outstanding. The drama is about human nature good or bad, hope and despair, honour, duty, sacrifice, pushing man's limits to the extreme, fulfill your goals even if it means paying the highest price. A Master and Commander who is one of a kind, the kind that has the capacity to change the course of history, who does NOT compromise or takes the easy way out. The consequences of such leadership are described in a nuanced manner, not black or white and we can judge for ourselves. I love the humoristic undertone which creates a perfect balance between the very sad and more optimistic scenes.

reply

Agreed. At least an 8 or 9. Personally I give it a 10. It's an amazing film. Love the use of Corelli's concerto grosso in G minor.

reply

I also gave it a10 - the first time I saw it a 9, but after watching it more times I realized that I could find no weak scenes or flaws at all and that this actually was a movie on Masterpiece level. The score is absolutely beautiful as you said and the cinematography breathtaking. The acting is sublime in each end every performance and the plot is authentic and believable. Certainly not a 7 something in my opinion.

reply

It definitely does not get the recognition it deserves. Such a shame it ended with just this one film.

Assuming Direct Control

reply

Agreed, every time I watch it it gets better. I just elevated it to one of my rare 10s after being 9. It has some minor problems (what movie doesn't) but every other good part to it elevates it above its flaws. That's how I justify it anyway.

--- MY RATINGS ---
2001,F.Gump,S.Shank,A.Beauty:10 | TDK:6 | Avengers:4

reply

7.9 I'd gladly give it.
But I don't think it should break 8.

reply