Well given what board you are on, you are either pretty naive or ignorant to not know such changes happen all the time in adaptions. It's the lay of land. Hell even some of the very characters in this movie had had that treatment long before.
But even still I've drawn a line in other threads, but simply put this movie, it's remake and the seemingly dead now tv project all fall into the same pitfalls.
It's basic premise is a nerdy one at that. It's going to alienate people who aren't that smart right off the bat. The similar current projects tried mainly to keep it smaller on the onset no doubt for that very reason. Too much and you are going to limit your potential audience.
Now that being said, if we already have a smaller audience to work with period, you don't want something of a base breaker set up to your premise. Which quite frankly is what Alan Moore's original story does. it's a deconstruction crossover that he clearly aims more at telling a point and being an encyclopedia. This type of thing would kill a whole lot of the people who went into it looking for a big crossover fun.
And then what do you have left supporting this movie? Alan Moore fans? That about it? While such an audience is more then enough to support his comic book line, i'm not even going to take serious consideration it's enough for a movie franchise with massive special effects. The movie's got to appeal to more than that. So changing things to make it more appealing are kinda the go-to-thing.
For more food for thought look at Watchmen. A name that while comic fans get excited for I doubt has much more presence outside of it, suffered a huge decline in theaters. Which more then likely is due to fans of super heroes not liking the kind of story the movie (and comic they had no idea about) wanted to tell. Marvel has made a lot of money telling edited stories of their comics into movies, but most of them aren't the same type of stories Alan Moore tried/tries to tell in Watchmen or League.
To me the big question will come if the person in charge of this wants to honor much of what the comics did for a storyline or not. If they are they might offer more tidbits but i'm just not able to seriously suggest most people today are going to pick up Alan Moore's graphic novel and say "I think this is good enough for a movie without significant changes".
And even if i'm wrong in that, i feel certain you can mark my words, theater attendance would drop significantly in one week too. You sell people on "this is a massive crossover of a bunch of old famous book characters" and you deliver Alan Moore's LoEG, i hope you are prepared for a lot of disappointment in people that aren't devotees of Moore.
reply
share