MovieChat Forums > The Devil's Rejects (2005) Discussion > My BIG problem with this movie (Spoilers...

My BIG problem with this movie (Spoilers)


The idea to try and turn the villains into the victims just doesn't work, especially not in a horror series like this. This movie is particularly bad cos it's pretty clear that they want you to feel bad for the trio of murderers in the scene with the cop at the end. They clearly want you to actually care about the mother being murdered in prison, the film want's to basically act like the 3 villains are deserving of your sympathy.. when barely an hour before, they were literally raping a woman with a gun and cutting people's faces off to use them like masks.

This is Rob Zombies problem, he makes unlikable characters perform indefensible actions and be unrepentant in their *beep* and yet you're still expected to somehow root for them. I'm sorry but while the Rejects make really fun villains, they should not be turned into the victims purely because Rob can't think of a better plot for a sequel

reply

"The idea to try and turn the villains into the victims just doesn't work, especially not in a horror series like this. This movie is particularly bad cos it's pretty clear that they want you to feel bad for the trio of murderers in the scene with the cop at the end. They clearly want you to actually care about the mother being murdered in prison, the film want's to basically act like the 3 villains are deserving of your sympathy.. when barely an hour before, they were literally raping a woman with a gun and cutting people's faces off to use them like masks."

I don't see it this way.

It's an over the top revenge horror show, and some pretty entertaining characters:

Bill Mosely as Otis Driftwood

"There is no &uckin' ice cream in your &uckin' future."

William Forsyth as Sheriff Wydell

"What did you say about the King?"

and best of all, Sid Haig as Captain Spaulding

"What's the matter, kid? Don't ya like clowns?"


And the soundtrack rocks.







"I'm gonna have to be taking your car today. See I have some top secret clown business that supersedes any plans that you might have for this here vehicle."

reply

Oh I agree that those characters were fun, there were some great lines and as villains they worked. My problem is when the revenge kicks in and suddently the son of a victim is played as some kind of super villain and we're meant to root for Baby to escape, or want Captain Spaulding to wak up and pull the nails out of Otis's hand. It felt like Rob was trying to make them sympathetic, especially with that ending scene of them in super slow motion.

reply

"...This movie is particularly bad cos it's pretty clear that they want you to feel bad for the trio of murderers in the scene with the cop at the end. They clearly want you to actually care about the mother being murdered in prison, the film want's to basically act like the 3 villains are deserving of your sympathy…."

No disrespect, but I just don't get it that way. Sure they did the montage at the end where they are all a happy family, but that is all part of the satire. i think that overall the tone reminded me a lot of Tarantino's films.

I don't think Zombie wants you to sympathize about Mother Firefly getting gutted in the jail cell by Sheriff Wydell, they just wanted to show how deep his vengeance was, how far he would step outside of the law to exact his revenge.

reply

Wow, don't you dare to compare this utterate *beep* with Tarantino's movies. Tarantino always manage to make us like almost every characters, because even when they are scum, they are never complete scum. In The Devil's Rejects in another hand, there is for me absolutely nothing I can appreciate about them. They don't have any values nor any attractivness whatsoever. Come on, even Eli Roth managed to make the two american who were paying to murder those girls in Hostel Part.2 more likeable...

reply

this movie is easily better then jackie brown or hateful 8

reply

Well, that is your personal opinion and I absolutely disagree with you.

reply

Agree. It's exactly what you see on the screen - I don't see any attempt made here to get the audience to favour either side. It's more than clear they're all pretty *beep* crazy lol!

reply

it's pretty clear that they want you to feel bad for the trio of murderers in the scene with the cop at the end. They clearly want you to actually care about the mother being murdered in prison

Yeah, I felt the same way and was wondering if this was heading for an evil triumph ending, so I was frustrated with it, but at the end they were killed off anyway and now I'm a happy bunny.

I suspect they intentionally did that to grow frustration in viewers and to make the ending unpredictable. Actually it kept me in suspense until the last firefight whether the sickos get away with it or not.

Never throw away a chance for happiness too quickly...it can get to be a habit.

reply


"they were killed off anyway"....until 2019 when 3 From Hell came out that is.

reply

Well I must be an idiot because it worked on me. When they were first driving away, and we finally saw the police roadblock, I threw my arms up and said, "I can't take much more of this!" But most of all, I felt sad for the 3, and had felt sad since they were tied up in the house.

reply

Never felt any sympathy for them, although this is one of the very few movies where I was rooting for the psycho murderer. I knew they were gonna get ended and thought it was a cool way to end the movie. The only one I felt "sympathy" for was Charlie, because every scene he was in was pretty great. "Rhode Island reds! I like them." ..."Are you saying that I would cut the head off a chicken, stick my d!ck in it, F_ck it! And go ahhhh?

reply

he wasnt trying to make you feel sympathy for them but he wanted you to feel thaqt they were human as well an loved each other despite being killers the sheriff became like them in the end that was another point dont cross the line or you loose yourself he could have simply took them to jail an they would have easily gotten the death penalty or killed in prison but because he took the law into his own hands he caused his death

reply

the sheriff became like them


How? The sheriff tortured and tried to kill them because THEY HAD IT COMING. They, on the other hand, killed just for fun, they killed, tortured and even raped innocent people for fun. No, the sheriff didn't become like t

reply

"This movie is particularly bad cos it's pretty clear that they want you to feel bad for the trio of murderers in the scene with the cop at the end."

Really? Well, they failed big time. Never in my movie experience (well if we consider TV shows, Sons of Anarchy is a serious contender as well) did I hate the main characters as much. They were abysmal pieces of trash.

reply

I think it is more like Hannibal Lector movies, where you just enjoy the characters even though they are evil and need to be defeated.


reply