MovieChat Forums > Spider-Man 3 (2007) Discussion > Spider man vs Amazing spider man IMDB ra...

Spider man vs Amazing spider man IMDB rate

posted 8 years ago by lost_dream
3 replies | jump to latest

I don't agree with IMDB rate and i think i understated why ASM have better rate than old SM , its like what old generation people like me vs new generation people who like new tings , i love old spider man and the character i see Kirsten Dunst more beautiful than Emma Stone , i see Tobey Maguire better actor than Andrew Garfield , but most of the people will disagree with me and mostly new generation :)

[–] Phill24 8 years ago

Andrew Garfield is a much better actor than Tobey Maguire, because Andrew Garield actually has charisma. A brick wall as more charisma than Tobey Maguire.

And Emma Stone as Gwen Stacy is way more likeable than Kirsten Dunts as Mary Jane. Mary Jane was a bitch in the Rami films. Yes, she was attractive, but aside from that I never got what Peter saw in her.

[–] mh-newressistance 8 years ago

Andrew Garfield is a much better actor than Tobey Maguire

Being more often in films doesn't mean better.

because Andrew Garield actually has charisma.

And fake American accent.

A brick wall as more charisma than Tobey Maguire.

Marlon Brando didn't have any charisma. Would you consider him a bad actor?

And Emma Stone as Gwen Stacy is way more likeable than Kirsten Dunts as Mary Jane.

When she died, I didn't really care for her, because filmmakers made her too independent, thus more stupid. It was her fault that she died in the movie, because it was her choice to get involved in the battle with Electro. In comics, she died because Goblin came to their apartment seeking for Spider-Man, but Peter wasn't there at the time, so he decided to kidnap her.

Mary Jane was a bitch in the Rami films.

A lot of Spider-Man girlfriends in comics were acting like bitches.

Yes, she was attractive, but aside from that I never got what Peter saw in her.

He tells you what he saw in her in the beginning of the first film when he walks into the bus.

[–] lost_dream 8 years ago

Like i said a lot of people will disagree with me , Mary Jane had that sadness on her eyes and spider man was more i don't know what to call it but he act more responsible , amazing spider man was like a teenage movie for me . its like SM movie made for old people and ASM for teenage people .

BTW i judge the movie depending on the movie not according to the comic as i think most of the people like amazing SM becasue its more similar to the comic and i read comic so thats one of the reason may be i like SM more than ASM .