MovieChat Forums > The Blind Side (2009) Discussion > This (racist) movie annoyed Michael Oher

This (racist) movie annoyed Michael Oher


Michael Oher is really, really frosted that they made it look like Leigh Anne Tuohy had to show him how to play football.

Oher wrote this book to explain to kids that there is more to escaping a life of great poverty and need than waiting around to be adopted by rich people. He wrote it to recognize some of the other people besides the Tuohys (about whom he writes with tremendous love and devotion) who were so important to the changes in his life. He wrote it to offer advice to those who have heard the story and want to help kids who are in the foster care system.

But if I had to guess what put him over the top, and what made this naturally reticent guy decide to pull the trigger and work on a book about himself, I'd guess it was the scene in the film where Sandra Bullock, as Leigh Anne Tuohy, drags him around football practice explaining what blocking is. Oher devotes only a couple of paragraphs to his reaction to the film, but here's part of what he has to say:

I felt like it portrayed me as dumb instead of as a kid who had never had consistent academic instruction and ended up thriving once he got it. Quinton Aaron did a great job acting the part, but I could not figure out why the director chose to show me as someone who had to be taught the game of football. Whether it was S.J. moving around ketchup bottles or Leigh Anne explaining to me what blocking is about, I watched those scenes thinking, 'No, that's not me at all! I've been studying — really studying — the game since I was a kid!' That was my main hang-up with the film.

But ultimately, what's really interesting about the book isn't just the correcting of the record about his knowledge of football. It's in the title, in fact: I Beat The Odds. It's true, of course. Poverty, foster care, spotty school attendance, living in an unsafe environment with a frequently absent mother — there are a lot of reasons why, statistically speaking, the odds were not with young Michael.

What the story underscores as he tells it is just how many things have to happen for those odds to be overcome. Of course, it begins with Oher himself, and an impressive determination not to repeat his mother's life. (Interestingly, he says he believed from a young age that sports would be his exit strategy, though he originally thought it would be basketball.)

But think about it: Here's a guy who had a certain number of built-in tools to work with. He's intelligent, he's determined, he stayed largely (if not totally) out of trouble, and — oh, right — he has a level of innate athletic ability, as well as a physical build, that has allowed him to become a professional football player.

And yet.

And yet, when you read his story, what resonates is how many other people had to get involved in order for him to get as far as college at Ole Miss (putting aside the great fame and fortune of the NFL). Let's start tallying.

He had friends who were as determined as he was to get out. He had brothers and sisters who helped keep him alive. He had a social worker who, he now understands, was making tenacious efforts to keep track of him as he was making equally tenacious efforts to evade her. He had foster families which, while very uneven, included some placements where he was exposed to discipline and routine and was made to go to school.

Later, he zeroed in on the Hendersons, a friend's family already living outside the projects that had achieved some of what he wanted for himself, and he stuck close. That's the family that brought him to Briarcrest, the private school where he met the Tuohys. Then Briarcrest accepted him, a variety of school families took him in for a few nights here and there, the Tuohys took him in permanently, he got a private tutor who was utterly devoted to him, he took correspondence courses to bring his grades up ...

This is the picture he's trying to paint in this book. What happened in his life is instructive not because the process was magical like it looks in the movie, but because it's so enormously daunting. This is what was required — this level of heavy lifting by everyone, starting with Oher, and the additional advantages afforded by the Tuohys' willingness to share some of their considerable wealth — this is what it took to turn things around for a guy who started out as an amazing natural athlete with rare gifts and a passionate desire to change his life.


http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2011/02/08/133590180/beyond-the-bli nd-side-michael-oher-rewrites-his-own-story

reply

Michael Oher is really, really frosted...
What a racist choice of words.

reply

That scene with Tuohy instructing Oher is rather ridiculous. Football is the most popular sport in the USA, and Oher somehow didn't know the most basic facts about blocking? Young, untrained players can be beaten easily, but it is more about not knowing the technique. Amusing scene obviously designed for Bullock to play what she is good at, but complete nonsense. Oher HS coach probably was hopping mad watching this movie.

reply

There are roughly 290 million people in the US who know how to drive a car, but do you think they could be dropped into competition on a NASCAR race track? There are a huge number of people who know how to stay on a horse without falling down, but how many would be able to run a steeplechase or dressage course? Lots of people can kick an inflated rubber spheroid, but how many make it into the World Cup?

Just knowing the rules of the sport (and there are DAMNED few people who actually know all the rules of professional football) doesn't automatically make one a pro football player, and everyone has to learn how to do it at some time. And you don't have to be a professional football player to be able to teach someone how to think like a professional football player.

reply

Soccer.

Soccer is the single most popular sport in the US.

Soccer.

reply

The football scenes are pretty ridiculous but to be fair this isn't really a movie about football. Most football movies are not accurately portrayed at all and I would say the last realistic football movie was Any Given Sunday.

reply

Or The Waterboy.

reply

The Waterboy was actually a documentary, so everything in it is exactly true.

reply

To be fair, it's not really a film about acts of random kindness either. It's a feel good film for a certain kind of white audience.

reply

What's so wrong with that? Why do you hate white people so much?

reply

It's a feel good film for a certain kind of white audience.
Why do you hate white people so much?

I'm a little disappointed that you didn't take it all the way to "Why do you hate America?" ;)

reply

And yet you refused to answer the question...

reply

"White" audience? Thank God there's nothing racist about bashing a race of people based on a stereotype, or you'd be waving a GIANT red flag here...

See, racism is racism, whether you are stereotyping/badmouthing black people OR white people.

reply

Remember the Titans?????

reply

Love that movie, and I hate football.

reply

Wtfh?

reply

This movie wasn’t racist. It played to common racial stereotypes but that doesn’t necessarily make it racist.

“I felt like it portrayed me as dumb instead of as a kid who had never had consistent academic instruction and ended up thriving once he got it. Quinton Aaron did a great job acting the part, but I could not figure out why the director chose to show me as someone who had to be taught the game of football. Whether it was S.J. moving around ketchup bottles or Leigh Anne explaining to me what blocking is about, I watched those scenes thinking, 'No, that's not me at all! I've been studying — really studying — the game since I was a kid!' That was my main hang-up with the film.”

Very interesting! It would have been much better if they stayed true to the real Michael Oher’s prior football knowledge instead.

Still a decent movie though, quite an amazing story with concepts of generosity, perseverance and work ethic that many people miss because they can’t see past race.

reply

@The Classic

Sorry, but if something plays to common racial stereotypes,then that's exactly what the hell it is---racist. How on earth could it be anything else?

BTW, here's some recent comments by Mr. Oher on being asked about the film,his life since the film, and how his career is going these days:

http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/nfl-shutdown-corner/beyond-blind-sid e-ravens-tackle-michael-oher-just-103543789--nfl.html

reply

Psh what the hell does he know. This is a true story! Right? Right....?

/sarcasm

_____________________________________________________________

Live and learn. At least we lived.

reply

This movie reflects the same stuff my foster parents did.

They had 2 children of their own, adopted 4, and fostered me.

Throughout the year and a half I lived with them, there were at least 5 people who lived with us(Outside of their adopted son and myself) who were having various trouble at home and needed someplace to live.

In the summer the loaned out the house for a summer school for Easter Seals that hosted special needs kids(It was kind of a pain in the summer when this thing would start at 7 am).

Throughout the years before I had lived for them, they had hosted a few other programs, plus had their kids(Natural and adopted) bring home friends of all walks of life that resulted in a town of 25,000 with serious gang problems having an "off limits" house. The doors were never locked, and pretty much the entire town knew it.

As a more immediate bonus when I was in high school, it was the default position that my foster mom would cook for about 20, no matter what. Inviting people over to eat was pretty much just "Hey, stay for dinner", and there was always food. No question, no adjusting what was available, or portions. We could pretty much invite the entire school, and there would be food for all.

While I may have had my own problems with my foster parents, they were the most awesome people I've met.

reply

those scenes are for people who dont know football. Its explaining it to the audience

reply

[deleted]

If this movie is racist, then I know longer know what "racist" is.

reply

lol @ the OP. You're an American, aren't you. You guys think everything is racist.

reply

lol @ the OP. You're an American, aren't you. You guys think everything is racist.

Sadly, that is an accurate assessment of a large percentage of Americans, especially in the media and Hollywood. In this country, smearing your opponent with a 'racist' smear is the intellectual equivalent of punching below the belt.

reply

Agreed... Everyone has gone pc mad

reply

I'd say you never knew. It was never only about calling people *beep* kiddo.

reply

I always liked the scene where he's pointing at a balloon floating in the sky..he was practically drooling on himself...

reply