MovieChat Forums > The Blind Side (2009) Discussion > Race, Football and the South

Race, Football and the South


It always amazes me how College Football is practically religion to white Southerners. If you look in the stands in a big SEC game you will 99.9999 percent white people, but 95% of the star players are black. Let's consider that the SEC didn't have any black players until the early 1970s! The only reason they integrated was becasue they were getting beaten by teams with black players. It seems that if you run a 4.2 40 yard dash,and score Touchdowns, Southerners will overlook the fact that you are black.

I have spent enough time in the South to know that unspoken social segregation is still the norm rather than the exception. Its a corny, feel good movie, but the reality is that southern whites are born every advantage, and black have everything stacked against them. This explains the terrible economic disparity. If all the those moral upright southern christian folk really practised what they preached it might be different. I think there are a lot of white people that think that issues of race are behind us, I kind of got that message from this film. There is still deep racism in this country, especially in the south.

I also have to that Mrs Tooey's her sense of "sytle" is just gawdy rich folk crap. The way they dress, their houses are all about conveying their wealth and status. Nothing that ever comes out of the South is any way stylish.

reply

And sentiment like this displays why a lot of Southerners consider "damnyankee" to be one word.

reply

some of the most deprecatory anti-southern sentiment has come from southerners themselves

reply

chas, you really don't know much about the South. Thanks for watching, though. And I'm still wondering about your sentence "I also have to that Mrs Tooey's her sense of "sytle" is just gawdy rich folk crap." Care to go back and make some sense of that miscellany of random letters?

ncw, you're right. I'll cite Erskine Caldwell as an example of that. But it's one thing to draw on a solid base of experience and criticize your own situation in an attempt to improve it. It's another thing entirely to mouth off on a topic about which you're clueless just to be offensive, as chas did.

reply

fair enough, but i'd like to know more about what you think chas got wrong

reply

Take a look at his second paragraph. Pretty much everything in it was garbage.

Southern whites have every advantage? Please. Very few people in the South lead lives that I would call privileged. We just consider ourselves normal people who work for a living.

Racism explains the terrible economic disparity? Guess again. IMO, the disintegration of the black family explains pretty much all problems that modern blacks (as a group) have. Generally speaking, blacks who grow up in a two-parent family tend to do pretty well. Those born illegitimate or to dysfunctional families have a harder time. White people are not a causal factor in that problem.

Then there's that statement about deep racism in the south. I could cite any of a number of incidents of racism elsewhere in the country. Here's just one.

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2011/12/10/new-york-girls-hoops-team-suspend ed-over-racist-chant/

Now, I'm a college football fan. I follow my team and the players on it, many of whom are black. But it's not like I cheer for them despite the fact that they're black. I care about them as human beings, I hope they get their degrees, perhaps go in to the NFL, and live successful lives. I don't look at it like I'm using someone whom I basically despise.

Bottom line: chas comes across as a shallow person who has a simplistic and condescending view of others.

reply

so you deny that, on a per capita basis, bigotry is more prevalent in the south?

>>>But it's not like I cheer for them despite the fact that they're black. I care about them as human beings<<<

i'm sure you do

do you get a chance to go up north very often?

reply

I don't know how you'd measure racism or calculate it per capita. Form my experience, some southerners are open racists, and some northerners are discreet racists.

BTW, no, I don't go up north very frequently. I've lived there on occasion, though --- DC (I consider it to be northern) and NYC. I've also lived in Japan and Germany.

reply

"From my experience, some southerners are open racists, and some northerners are discreet racists."

I grew up on the West Coast and went to college in the South.

Bigotry and racism exist in both places, yet present very differently.

In the South, people tend to be more open about racist views and attitudes, yet manage to live and work with people of other races. In the West, racists tend to keep it quiet, but avoid people of races that they don't like.
In the South, racism is mostly about blacks and whites. In the West, racism is about blacks, whites, Hispanics, Asians, etc. and some of the most bitter racism is between blacks and Hispanics.



The one common denominator was that bigotry and racism go both ways in both places

reply

I know plenty about the SOUTH, I spent more time there than I care to admit and have the horror stories to tell. I'm exactly right in everything I say. Southern Man.....Mrs Tooey's sense of style is just "gawdy rich folk crap."

reply

It's interesting that you mention "Southern Man." We know that Young wrote that after being beaten up at a southern bar, probably for shooting his mouth off. So the song was motivated by less moral outrage and more by personal bitterness than he let on. I suspect that's the case with your posts, too.

reply

[deleted]

Wow! Bigotry, prejudice, and ignorance all wrapped in one sentence! Good job!

reply

[deleted]

1) The word is "later", not "latter."

2) Yes, I am calling you bigoted and prejudiced, which is never a compliement, although I guess I am not surprised you would be proud of that.

3) You can certainly label it a "lame attempt," I don't care. I am just pointing out the obvious.

reply

[deleted]

Hoist by my own petard. That serves me right for trying to be snarkey Yes, you are correct.

Well, that just goes to show that someone who makes ignorant, bigoted, and racist statements can get his English usage correct.

Congratulations! You can do one thing well!

Edited: Oh yes, I also need to thank you for the vote of genius. I have multiple degrees in math, and it was kind of you to overlook my failing in English.

reply

There's NOTHING good about Southerners (unless lynchings and chanting racial slurs is considered "good").
Why do you think all Southerners participate in these things?

reply

y'all come back now ya' here!



Where there's smoke, there's barbecue!

reply

I'm pretty proud of starting this thread

"For dark is the suede that mows like a harvest"

reply

You must be a Big 10 fan. Recruit the south better and you might actually win a title.


Haters gonna hate

reply

I know many people who have migrated south and agree with your postion. Also, IMO, they don't sound very Christian...

God is real. Atheists don't exist

reply

I have spent enough time in the South to know that unspoken social segregation is still the norm rather than the exception.
That's interesting- I moved from the South to the North a year and a half ago, and I have encountered more racism ad segregation up here than I ever did living in Virginia, Florida and Georgia. A few Confederate flag tattoos and clothing with the declaration that it had NOTHING to do with Southern pride, and more to do with racist beliefs, a noose hanging from a pickup, etc.. I never experienced anything so disgusting in the South.

My theory is that there was so much emphasis placed on the South and their issues with race, and little attention paid to the North- so while the South would have made great strides, the North wouldn't have due to an ignorant assumption that everything was ok in that respect.

I guess we all have different experiences, eh?

The night is a very dark time for me.

reply

Yes, we all have had different experiences and have different perspectives. No doubt racism is humanity at its worst and that it still persists, despite the declaration that Obama's election would usher in the post-racial era. The murder of an innocent black teen this past week in Florida tells me that we still have a long way to go as a Nation.

My experience in the South was working long stints in rural Louisiana, Arkansas and east Texas. I never saw overt racism, in the form of violence or confrontation, although among the rural white southerners I worked with, the "N Word" flowed freely. Coming from New Mexico of all places, I did notice certain things about the rural South immediately. First, it was obvious from the beginning, that the different races stuck together, and there was very little interaction unless it were work related, etc. The African American communities in these small towns, all lived in the same neighborhoods, went to the same churches and almost always worked the lower paying jobs. This is what I refered to as the unspoken social segregation. I think its a mechanism southerners have come up with to avoid confrontation.

A few more obsevations about the original topic of this thread; one has only to us the "eye ball" test when watching an SEC football game. The teams are well over 50% African American, while a quick pan to the student cheering section shows an almost lilly white audience. The fact is that most African Americans that go to college in the South are still attending the "Negro Colleges", and only the elite athletes go to the State schools. This may be changing, and I hope it is. My impression is that the urban "New South" has made real strides in the area of race relations. But the rural South, which is still the majority, is very reluctant to change. Interesting that Obama won a landslide (by today's electoral standards) in 2008, yet McCain won every Southern State with ease (except N Carolina).

reply

The murder of an innocent black teen this past week in Florida tells me that we still have a long way to go as a Nation.
There isn't any evidence in that case whatsoever to indicate racist motives other than the victim being black (which of course, isn't evidence or indicative of that by itself). Not sure why it's relevant.
Interesting that Obama won a landslide (by today's electoral standards) in 2008, yet McCain won every Southern State with ease (except N Carolina)
Not that interesting. Democrats generally have a hard time making a dent in Southern states- it wasn't peculiar to the last election.

The night is a very dark time for me.

reply

Well actually, during Zimmerman's 911 call, he is heard saying "the coons always get away". So it falls into the profiling category. This guy had called 911 something like 46 times complaining about suspicious young Afro American males walking in their neighborhood. So, it was a racial incident and will likely be a "hate crime" prosecution. The "stand your ground" law no doubt was meant to give fine upstanding folks the right to murder suspicious looking characters and get away with it.

Anyhow, discussions like this usually aren't very productive. Race and the South are very touchy subjects. My bad for even bringing it up.

reply

The "coons" thing has yet to be proven- it sounds more like he said "punks". The neighborhood had a series of break ins from burglars that fit the description of young black male, so I don't see why being suspicious of someone that fits the description of recent criminals in the area would be racist.

The Stand Your Ground law is intended to allow victims to use force to defend themselves, and it is wholly irrelevant in the Trayvon Martin case. It does not protect the aggressor, which will most likely be proven to be George Zimmerman. If anyone had the right to use that law, it was Trayvon.

The night is a very dark time for me.

reply

Obama won both VA and FL which last I checked are still considered the south. There is plenty of bigotry that still exists in the north. It is much more covert.
This did seem like the age old condescending Hollywood banality which portrays blacks as inept until "caring whitey" swoops in to rescue them from their plight. Having minority friends who are educated and successful convinces me that avoiding this weak attempt at cloying sentiment was the correct choice.

reply

The South didn't vote against Obama because he's black. It voted against him because he's very liberal. I didn't vote for McCain for the same reason I didn't vote for Obama.

If Colin Powell, Thomas Sowell, Walter Williams, Condoleeza Rice, Herman Cain, or Alan Keyes had run in 2008, I would have voted for them.

reply

There are a lot of generalities being through around here. I'm from Kentucky and have lived in both the deep south and north and have found that our major east coast cities are far more racist than anywhere else. DC and Baltimore have some serious race relation issues. I'm not shielding the southern states from their faults but there are a lot of strong race relations and the vast majority of people dont treat people that differently.

reply

[deleted]

Your professor was a southern mole. Every so often, we send them out to discourage the gullible from visiting our fair land. This tactic seems to have worked wonders on the OP.

reply

I don't think anyone can say anything about any place until they actually go there. I have lived in the south my entire life. While there is plenty of racism, some backwards ways of thinking and intolerance, there are a lot of good people here who have great morals and spirits.

You can't say just because there are negative aspects of a place that it speaks for all of it. I take offense to it personally. I'm from the south and I'm not even a big college football fan. Ooooohh wow..... Nor am I a racist or a bigot. Imagine that.

There are plenty of people everywhere who are fu**** up. How about in California where a baseball fan was nearly beaten to death? Or that horrific school shooting in Sandy Hook? Those events happened in different places all over the country. But I'm not going to go to California and think that I'm going to get beaten or go to Connecticut and think some crazy fool is going to shoot me. Now these examples may be different in terms of speaking culturally, but If you think the actions of a few or many people speak for the entire region then you are sorely mistaken.

Racism, bigotry and immorality exists all over the place. As do harsh living conditions. As do insane sports fanatics.

And this movie is really bad.

reply

Spoken like a true Yankee. You probably thought Deliverance was a documentary.

reply