MovieChat Forums > Game of Thrones (2011) Discussion > "I read the book and followed the instru...

"I read the book and followed the instructions"


Best line in the episode

reply

Either that or Ser Davos introducing Jon Snow "This is Jon Snow..............King of the North."

reply

Both were unintentionally hilarious lines.

reply

I think they were meant to be funny.

reply

Funny to the audience. Not in the context of the story.

reply

Quite the intentional line by Ser Davos. After the long recitation of Daenerys' titles he could have said "This is Jon Snow, son of Ned Stark, Lord Commander of the Night Watch, Lord of Winterfell, Pacifier of Wildlings, Slayer of White Walkers, and King in the North."

Nope. He was direct and to the point which actually made Daenerys look ridiculous.

There was nothing unintentional about it.

reply

Ok. I don't know why this is becoming a thread. I saw them as funny jibes for the audience. Within the context of the story, they were delivered as matter of fact and not taken well by either Dany or the Maester.

reply

I'm not trying to argue with you; it's just that I loved the lines and thought that they were calculated and intentional. But if you feel otherwise, cool. It's just a matter of perception and opinion.

I've mentioned why I think Ser Devos answered the way he did. Sam as well, the implication is that the instructions were there, were clear, therefore there is a cure for the greyscale and it is known, and the Maester was being a coward for allowing people to die from it instead of implementing the procedure that could cure them.

reply

Fair enough

reply

I like your interpretation, that it was intentional on Davos' part.

reply

That was Hillarious!!!

reply

He is also "Knower of Nothing"

reply

LOL, nice!

reply

Also, he had the courage to try it in the first place, knowing he could contract greyscale himself.

I suspect the maesters' fear was the greatest barrier to attempting a cure.

reply

True.

reply

I wonder if the scrolls the archmaester assigned Sam to copy were related to the white walkers.

reply

Hopefully. That would move the plot along well. I am curious to see if there is anything to know about the White Walkers that would be helpful. At this point we know what kills them and we ostensibly know what motivates the Night King based on his origin. Is there anything left to know, like does he have an ultimate goal or is it just to turn the entire world into the walking dead?

reply

I think there is more to know about him. When the real battle starts I believe we'll learn more.

reply

I wonder if D&D will stick to their guns and not give him any dialogue or if he will finally speak before the battle is over.

reply

I hope he does speak and then he says some chilling (pun intended) things.

reply

Ha, I see what you did there.

reply

Something like: "I'm Night's King... King of the North."

reply

»I wonder if the scrolls the archmaester assigned Sam to copy were related to the white walkers.«

My thoughts exactly!
Giving him that seems like a punishment in order to keep his face, but in fact giving Sam what he asked for as a reward.

reply

It reminds me of how, during the Black Death, a lot of doctors would simply refuse to try to treat patients out of fear of contracting it themselves. I was just reading about that recently. Of course the plague was more contagious than greyscale, due to physical contact being required for the latter. But still.

reply

As a side note, I thought it was a bit reckless for the Archmaester to just let Jorah go like that and not quarantine Sam for a few days. Considering how relatively little seems to be known of greyscale and how low the odds are of successful treatment, as well as the risk of the person doing the procedure contracting greyscale in the process, it seems to me it would be prudent to wait and see for a few days before just turning Jorah loose and letting Sam go on with his normal duties.

Of course, we can guess that it had already been a few days, but that seems unlikely given that the Archmaester gave Jorah one day to decide his fate and it was clearly their first conversation since then.

reply

lol that was funny as hell.

reply

Much as I enjoy this discussion, it's focus has shifted away from its object, which is the endearing Samwell Tarly. I think Sam is a character too often overlooked. Clearly, he is a true scholar, and that is the meat of the quotation that is this topic's title: something so simple, yet so RARELY done. In my experience as a consumer electronics professional, almost NO ONE reads any instructions, nor follows them. Why not? Because doing that requires two things: work, and brains. In the case of operating on Ser Jorah, it also required faith and guts. Here's something else to consider: Sam has a son of a cunt father who encouraged him even less (if that's possible) than Tywin supported Tyrian--yet look at all that he has accomplished. He's killed a fucking White Walker! And his love for Gilly is inspiring. Please, don't stop posting; but can you also spare a thought, and possibly a word, for overlooked Samwell Tarly? Thank you.

reply