hmmm...


I'll keep watching, because I'm curious. But I'm not enthralled, and if it doesn't improve soon, I'll hope for a cancellation (I'd rather that than just stop watching, which I know is always an option, because I'm a bit of a completionist that way).

And I've read and loved all three books, so yeah, I'm making comparisons. If that bugs you, or you don't want potential spoilers (not doing a deep dive into the future though), or if you want to commiserate, whatever.

Amy's back story is sooo rushed. That's always so irritating on TV. I understand things get cut with adaptations. But the argument is often made that television is a better medium than film for character development, for the obvious of more time. So it stings a bit more when things get cut on TV. It's been a while since I've read the books, so I can't recall exact details, but there was a lot more to it. Amy's mom was convinced in some manner to abandon Amy at an orphanage run by nuns. We got a bit more of Amy growing up, and I think there was some weird incident at the zoo, Omen-style. She's taken from the orphanage by the agents when she's 6. They aged her up for the show. Probably broadens the pool of child actors to choose from, and makes it slightly more palatable for the audience. There was one nun, Lacey, who really loved Amy and came after her and plays a larger part in the story, but looks like she's been written out.

Can't recall if Wolgast had a kid in the books.

The opening scene in Bolivia is much more drawn out in the book, and has the whole team lost in the jungle and being attacked by bats, was really creepy.

Not to mention that the primary timeline from the book is nowhere to be seen, which is a colony 93 years later, after humanity is gone. Maybe that's how they'll end Season 1, then go there if they get a Season 2. Though the problem is I don't feel like they'll want to mess with having to find an almost entirely new cast.

I don't get The Walking Dead comparisons, this feels much more like The Strain.

reply

Your post really resonates with me. Although I can safely say that I have no problem dropping any series that feels subpar or falls beneath my expectations. Life is too short.
I'm still going to give it a chance.

I had high expectations after reading the books but lower ones after hearing it had actually been picked up by FOX network. In the hands of someone like HBO it would've had a much better chance for a decent adaption. And even then it would be difficult with the time jumps and multitude of various characters.
It feels obvious to me that the writers will probably trim out major parts of the story until it will only vaguely resemble the original.
This is network...too much exposition already..They must tell, not show. Everything is being rushed and simplified. You're right about that.

I have read that the character of Lacey (very important in the book) will show up in a modified and completely altered way..We'll see how that goes.
As we'll see if they even tackle the time jump to the Colony.... If it lasts or if they're up to the task to try and tell this story.
Or a network homogenized version instead..



reply