MovieChat Forums > My Sister's Keeper (2009) Discussion > In the book was it Kate's idea?

In the book was it Kate's idea?


Or just in the movie? I keep hearing that the movie has quite a few differences, especially the ending...

reply

It was Kate's idea in the book as well.

**SPOILER**
If you want to know how the book ends, scroll down...














































Anna and Campbell get into a car accident. Anna dies, Kate gets her kidney and survives.

reply

Yeah I had already heard how it ended. I think I like the film ending better. The two endings seem to be the difference between choice or fate and I prefer choice...

reply

It was Kate's idea in the book too, which I found to be extremely selfish.

reply

How is that selfish? She was sick of it all (no pun intended) and she wanted to die. She also wanted to give her sister a chance at a normal life. That really doesn't seem selfish at all.

reply

it kind've annoyed me that is was actually kate's idea, i thought the concept of abigail breslin's character refusing to be forced/guilted into these procedures and taking control over her own body was an interesting one, especially as kate seemed throughout the movie to have little problem with it and understand what her sister wanted. this concept was made even better for me by the complete unlikeability of the mother (i hated her in this movie, she was horrible).
i still think it's a good movie and the idea of the law suit and all being kate's still works really well but i was just a little let down when i learned this during the movie.

"this is not nam dude, this is bowling, there are rules."

reply

I think the idea of being forced or guilted into procedures goes both ways. When you are chronically ill (especially as a child) there is a lot of pressure and expectation that you do as you're told, go through procedures and tests and basically give up your body to various professionals. It's very, very easy to lose the feeling of your body being your own, you lose all vestiges of personal space and autonomy. You stop being a person and just become a body. It's incredibly difficult, especially when you are a child or teenager and all of the conversations about you are happening between your parents and the doctors.

reply