MovieChat Forums > Sons of Anarchy (2008) Discussion > The Show’s Writing Goes From Being Engro...

The Show’s Writing Goes From Being Engrossing To Preposterous SPOILERS


I’ve been binging SOA, and I was becoming increasingly invested in it—until, at the end of S5, Otto murders a prison nurse who just HAPPENS to be the sister of a vendetta-driven US Marshal, who grows a hard-on the size of Detroit and the rigidity of carborundum steel for the Sons and everyone connected to them, e. g., Tara?! No. Sorry. We just hit melodramatic soap opera territory. The probability of that coincidence being plausible is less than that of the Pope declaring Hitler a saint. I am now dialed out of my binge. I’m willing to suspend my disbelief, when the story is good. I’m not willing to have my intelligence insulted when the writers have run out narrative developments that are better than “and then s/he woke up and realized it had all been a dream,” or “the dead nurse is the sister of a rule-breaking and brutal former US Marshal.”

reply

You're really gonna love what happens at the end of the second last season, as the entire last season is focused on it. One big lie.

reply

No, I won’t. I’ve stopped watching. It’s insulting.

reply

I figured. Just saying, there's more soap opera antics that come afterwards. There's plenty in the earlier seasons as well, like how Gemma teleports around the place sometimes.

reply

Thank you. I appreciate your info.

reply

I found season 6 to be okay, definitely not that good, but watchable. Season 7 is the one that made it almost unbearable for me. At that point I only watched because I knew it was the last season. I think it was that bad because Kurt Sutter took over writing completely. He's a good showrunner, but an awful writer. At least for long term storylines. I'm sure he wrote a lot of episodes in seasons 1 through 5 that were good, but in season 7 it was all his vision, and it sucked.

reply