MovieChat Forums > Dune (2021) Discussion > Frank Herbert’s Son Visited ‘Dune’ Set a...

Frank Herbert’s Son Visited ‘Dune’ Set and Said It’ll ‘Forever Be the Definitive Adaptation’


Brian Herbert, son of legendary “Dune” author Frank Herbert, had one major takeaway after visiting the Budapest set of Denis Villeneuve’s upcoming adaptation of his father’s science-fiction epic: “It will forever be considered the definition adaptation” of the book (via Inverse). Villeneuve’s “Dune” is backed by Legendary and Warner Bros. and features a star-studded cast that includes Timothée Chalamet, Zendaya, Jason Mamoa, Rebecca Ferguson, Dave Bautista, and Stellan Skarsgard. The film was originally scheduled to open in theaters December 18, but the pandemic pushed the tentpole into October 2021.

Prior to Villeneuve’s anticipated take on Herbert’s novel, other attempts to adapt “Dune” for the screen mostly failed. Alejandro Jodorowsky famously tried to get a “Dune” movie off the ground in the 1970s but the project never made it past the development stage. David Lynch’s 1984 adaptation was a critical failure, one that remains a tragic experience for the director after his creative control was taken away by the studio.
https://www.indiewire.com/2020/12/frank-herbert-son-dune-set-visit-dazzled-1234602509/

reply

that's cool, but it looks overly average to me, where as the old crappy one, went over the top and will always be more interesting to me. Not sure why yet another remake was even needed? Did someone ask for it? It will only piss off the fans of the book for not being PERFECT, and the story is half baked, and not all that interesting to begin with. Oh well, I wish it luck for whomever really wants to enjoy it.

reply

i'm with you i am not impressed with what i saw this far from the new version. got a really bad feeling.

reply

I wonder how much he got paid for helping to big it up ?

reply

Pretty sure he gets paid because his father basically owns the franchise.

reply

His father's been dead for decades. He gets paid because he's the executor of the estate and the copyright holder to his father's works.

reply

thats what i said

reply

Isn't he the son that is churning out piles of low quality Dune novels? Not sure that having him endorse it is a good thing in the eyes of fans of the original books. Plus, the endorsement probably came with piles of money. Everything I have seen so far looks bland and lifeless and has that over-produced look to it.

reply

I've seen the trailers (old and new) and it looks to me that Villaneuve is just updating David Lynch's vision/adaptation with more modern SFX/CGI.

I would probably have been more interested if Villanueve took more inspiration from the original failed film adaptation from the early 70s

reply