MovieChat Forums > Inception (2010) Discussion > Ellen Page was bad casting

Ellen Page was bad casting


Her shortness and abrasive personality bug me.

She's got the whole bossy thing down to an artform.

I think a more attractive woman was needed for such a stylish movie.

reply

Not every woman has to be a model in a movie.

reply

Also her character doesn't make much sense. He needs an "architect" and basically reveals all his secrets to her and hires her despite being unable to follow instructions and barely knowing her.


reply

What a dumb, shallow comment. A hotter woman would have been better? How old are you? Go watch a CW series.

reply

The problem with her character is that she didn't seem to have any real role in the plot, except to give the hero someone to talk to. Or talk at, she was really just there to help the exposition along.

Perhaps if she'd had a bit of romantic chemistry with DiCaprio it might have been a slightly different film, one where the anti-hero had to choose between his dead love and a real living woman. But as they didn't seem to have any connection other than work (and exposition dump), there was nothing along those lines. I don't think the movie was particularly well cast, I never liked DiCaprio, and neither he nor Page are big on providing romantic chemistry.

reply

I liked DiCaprio in this role. I thought that Joseph Gordon-Levitt looked a little too nerdy and couldn't really sell the action scenes.

I had problems with Ken Watanabe's English. I'm pretty good at understanding foreigners speaking so for me to struggle means he's really bad.

Marion Cotillard was amazing.

Cillian Murphy was just a pass.

Tom Hardy seemed to underplay his role a little too much.

reply

I cant believe that Tom Hardy took such a throwaway of a supporting role, he was wasted.

reply

Yeah, I was watching thinking 'Can't believe this is Bane'. He could have brought so much more to his part.

reply

that is tru nobody likes a british accent on a dude. it sounds sexy on a girl but if i guy talks like that he sounds like a nerd...

reply

LOL. Hollywood normally likes posh british accents on villains.

I liked Jude Laws accent until he decided to try an aussie accent in Contagion. It was terrible. He even threw in 'crickey!' which is not something Australians actually say unless they're over 70.

reply

Aussie accents are badass but the most narly one is South African

reply

That's an interesting accent, it does rub people up the wrong way in Australia though. They think it sounds arrogant.

reply

South Africans sound like they are always about to fight

reply

Yes, a hotter would have been better.

reply

true true a more attractive woman would have made this movie much more badass$$$$$$

reply

Too bad she is a lesbian, so it shouldn’t matter if heterosexual men find her attractive.

reply

"too bad"? bigot much?

reply

I meant that she is a lesbian, so heterosexual men shouldn’t judge if she is hot or not.

reply

The point of Cobb's arc in the film is his love for his very hot wife.

Having a secondary female character who was also hot would have insinuated a possible hook up.

To avoid that, you cast... average.

reply

boy figure

reply

Yes, there could have been a better likable actress.

reply

Maybe the character could've been made abit older and cast ScarJo (who was in The Prestige)

reply

I agree with you, she was very annoying and reckless. But I think this was how the character was written and was not really the actress. In fact, having a nerdy type in this role made more sense than the typical 6 foot model. As far as why she would go along with all this... that wasn't convincing to me. (They insinuated that she was well paid, and had intellectual curiosity, but that wasn't enough to casually break the law in my view)

reply