MovieChat Forums > Barbie (2023) Discussion > Ryan Gosling Criticizes Margot Robbie, G...

Ryan Gosling Criticizes Margot Robbie, Greta Gerwig Oscars Snubs


https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/ryan-gosling-margot-robbie-greta-gerwig-oscars-snub-1235805410/

reply

Other Directors were more deserving and guess what Ryan Gosling was the only good actor in the movie. That's a win for the Patriarchy.

reply

America Ferrera was nominated for best supporting actress, in a balanced fashion.

reply

She'll likely win due to her lame speech that all but sums up female privilege in a nutshell. Only in America can you claim to be a victim while benefiting from the privilege and entitlement that rigs everything in your favor. What a load of shit.

reply

She is more likely to win than Ryan Gosling, that is for sure.

reply

But the movie still received 8 nominations.

Margot Robbie's performance is hardly Oscar worthy.

Only Greta Gerwig was not nominated for best director is a surprise, since Barbie is nominated for best picture.

Oppenheimer being nominated for best picture is another surprise. The movie does not fit the oscar diversity criteria, maybe they have something like minority executives and minority intern programs.

So Nolan actually has a shot to win best director, it is probably his only shot.

How is Barbie not original screenplay, but nominated for "Adapted screenplay", adopted from what?

But I am glad Napoleon did not get any major nomination, it is just not a good movie.

reply

Oppenheimer being nominated was not a surprise. It got nominated for the PGA, DGA, SAG Ensemble, multiple BAFTA awards, multiple Golden Globes, multiple Critics Choice Awards and several other critics groups. Nolan is a lock to win and Oppenheimer will win multiple Oscars.

reply

Like I said before, the movie does not meet the diversity quota.

reply

It does meet the diversity rules. Only two of the four listed standards must be met by a film to be eligible for Best Picture. Oppenheimer could satisfy Standard B due to its executive producer, Thomas Hayslip, and costume designer, Ellen Mirojnick, being Asian and female, respectively, and therefore members of "underrepresented groups". Oppenheimer could also satisfy Standard D due to Universal Pictures, the film's distribution company, having a President of Domestic Marketing, Dwight Caines, who is African American and a President of Distribution, Veronika Kwan Vandenberg, who is a woman.

reply

I guess they thought through.

reply

Wasn't Oppenheimer also Jewish? Are they considered an underrepresented gropu according to the rules?

reply

I predicted both snubs. There were other directors and lead actresses that were more deserving.

reply

It should consider itself lucky. Gidzilla Minus One deserved to be nominated in best picture and director, as well as lead actor. J. A. Bayona deserved a nomination for directing Society of the Snow. Agustin Pardella, Matias Recalt, and Enzo Vogorinic all deserved nominations for actor. Micahel Giacchino deserved a nomination for best score for Society of the Snow, and Naoki Sato deserved one for Godzilla Minus One. Barbie got 8 nominations while other films were snubbed.

reply

Godzilla Minus One was not even nominated for 'International feature film', that is a surprise.

I am guessing monster movies are beneath oscar, but girly doll movies are not.

reply

"Godzilla Minus One" should be in the main films, not international. G-1 deserves to be in the main ten. But go ahead and pick films on one has heard of instead of recognizing how G-1 was a triumph for the film industry. But yeah, I guess girly doll films are more in line with Hollywood's form of entertainment.

reply

Japan submitted "Perfect Days" by Wim Wenders for International feature film. Each country can only submit one movie and Japan decided on this. We can be 100% sure that Godzilla would never ever win the Oscar, so it was a good move by Japan. But we can also look at France, who submitted this year the saver choice of The Taste of Things (very typical submission), snubbing Anatomy of a Fall.
We can only assume that the French jury not estimated the buzz Anatomy would create. Unfortunately the movie only started several weeks after submission closure. The best effects Oscar submission date was after the release of Godzilla in Japan mid of November.

reply

What if Best Picture came down to "Barbie" or Godzilla MINUS ONE" and Godzilla won?? How bad on a scale of 1-10 is there an uproar over it?? Accusations of sexism or some nonsense like that??

reply

Well, the whole cast of GM1 are not white. It'd be funny watching the activists lose it because they weren't the "right" kind of brown people.

reply

I hate when people say someone was snubbed but then they dont say who shouldn't have been nominated, which is the other side of the coin. Which best actress nominee would Gosling kick off?

reply

LOL maybe the academy just didn’t feel that Margot Robbie and Greta Gerwig were deserving. I mean there are plenty of years where I didn’t agree with the winners or nominees and I didn’t throw a temper tantrum and started blaming it on “isms” . People need to chill out and get over themselves.

reply

Well, it's not the kind of movie that particularly appeals to the Academy, is it -- and it's still got 8 nominations from folk who tend to favour adult-oriented dramas. Gerwig and Robbie have both been nominated for previous projects that were more Oscar-friendly. They probably know how this stuff works.

I don't think it should come as any great surprise to Gosling -- or anyone else -- that the year's biggest blockbuster has been acknowledged by the Academy, but isn't going to dominate the proceedings. Happens most years.

Besides, it made a gazillion dollars. If award ceremonies serve any purpose at all, it's in highlighting quality work that mainstream audiences may have previously overlooked. Gerwig and Robbie have both benefited from this tendency among the voters in the past and will probably both benefit from it in the future.

I don't think they have much to complain about here.

reply