MovieChat Forums > Z for Zachariah (2015) Discussion > Rip off from This Quiet Earth

Rip off from This Quiet Earth


The Quiet Earth, little known New Zealand film, but brilliantly done. Seems very similar!

http://m.imdb.com/title/tt0089869/

reply

Well apparently it was based on a book but storyline was changed

reply

Quiet earth is a fantastic movie, part of the area is now Sylvia Park mall

reply

Only one of the best Sci-fi movies ever made. We always joked about a US remake one day... I hope this isn't it.

http://www.1971-reviewae.com

reply

The Quiet Earth is a great film but Z for Zachariah is a 1974 novel which was originally made into a BBC drama in 1984 so it pre-dates The Quite Earth which was based on a 1985 novel.

reply

Doesn't predate The World The Flesh And The Devil. More Hollywood rehash.

reply

Quiet Earth the movie (1985) was loosely based on Quiet Earth the Book (1981)

It has more in common with the 1959 film The World, the Flesh and the Devil, of which it has been called an unofficial remake

I think both Z for Zachariah and Quiet Earth are both pulling from similar source material and neither is intentionally copying the other.

It's a pretty common recurring theme in sci fi.

reply

Writing anything completely original now must be very difficult - however both are enjoyable stories..

Try Inverted World by Christopher Priest if you're looking for something interesting but be careful of spoilers in any review you may look at. Avoid the review by Martin Amis.

reply

I was wondering about that from having read the plot if it was somehow connected to The Quiet Earth. Thanks for the thread, clears things up nicely.

reply