MovieChat Forums > Albert Nobbs (2012) Discussion > Does it have homosexuality issues?

Does it have homosexuality issues?


Does this movie involve homosexuality issues?



there r no shortcuts in life.every shortcut leads to consequences that make us stray from our path

reply

MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS

Quick answer = Yes.

While there is some question as to whether Mr. Nobbs himself is gay or no, there is little room for doubt concerning Hubert Page and his wife.

In the scenes where Mr. Nobbs joins them for supper, Hubert and Kathleen appear to be a very loving couple.

No, there is none of the typical left-wing H'wood preaching. It's handled with subtlty and without the in-your-face tripe that we're used to seeing in movies.

Just my $0.02.


"I can't bear labels."
~ Janet McTeer

reply

thanx


there r no shortcuts in life.every shortcut leads to consequences that make us stray from our path

reply

Issues? I wouldn't say issues. . . . Homosexuality was presented in the film, but considering the place and time. . .well, it wasn't exactly open.

reply

Homosexulity seems to be at the heart of this movie, although it is rather ambiguous. At first, I thought these women were posing as men due to economic necessity; later, it seems that "Mr." Page is definitely in a gay relationship (although she had been married to a man prior to this). She even explains to Albert later that they can't be together because they are not in love with one another. Albert's sexuality is even more ambiguous because he/she does not seem to be sexually attracted to the young woman or to Page, but rather wants her for companionship and to be less lonely. I really don't get her character.

reply





What I found annoying was that Hubert "turned" Lesbian because of the violence of her "first" husband. That's a bit of a movie staple: men = BAAAAD, have to get my love from a sensitive, caring woman.




No Guru, No Method, No Teacher.

reply

Yes, it was a rather puzzling film. . .. Nobbs seemed more of an asexual woman, although the freedom of running on the beach wearing a dress can't be denied. Again, I believe the time had a lot to do with it. Would Page have had to dress like a man today?

reply

I don't believe Hubert turned lesbian because of an abusive husband. She first lived as a man and was not about to give that up for it meant a lesser life. So once she decided she would live the rest of her life as a male, she had to start to question whether she would ever have a romantic relationship in her life or not. She would have to think about having a male partner and living as a male in public and as a female in private, or live always as a male and find a female partner. It's possible that she even met her wife without having decided any of this, but they had a connection that grew until it blossomed into what it became.

Another possibility was that she was bisexual and never "turned" in any way. Instead, she had explored her interest in males and was now exploring her interest in females.

reply