MovieChat Forums > Trolljegeren (2010) Discussion > Death by sunlight? Bad from an evolution...

Death by sunlight? Bad from an evolutionary point of view.


Trolls die as soon as they're exposed to sunlight. Why didn't such a severe evolutionary drawback eliminate the species long ago? How do they manage to live for between 1000 and 1200 years, when being outside for just a moment after sunrise will kill them? Given their size, I imagine they might have difficulty always finding a cave to hide in that will fit them until sunset, especially given their limited intelligence.

And let's not forget that in southern-mid Norway the sun is up for around 20 hours a day in midsummer, leaving only 4 hours of darkness for trolls so get out and hunt for food. This would also preclude the survival of trolls in northern Norway, where the sun doesn't set at all for several months in the summer, unless they can do all their hunting in the spring and survive on that while they hibernate in the caves in the summer.

reply

Maybe they hibernate in the summer and forage in the winter?

Of course you're right. But this is the way it is.

reply

Ha! Good points, making this movie even more ridiculous. If this was meant to be a comedy they should have made it funnier.

reply

Are you really trying to justify why Trolls couldn't exist by using modern scientific theory? Now THAT's funny!

reply

Trolls die as soon as they're exposed to sunlight. Why didn't such a severe evolutionary drawback eliminate the species long ago?
The problem is that you're confusing a silly troll legend with science. You might want to look into that.

reply

Trolls die as soon as they're exposed to sunlight. Why didn't such a severe evolutionary drawback eliminate the species long ago?


.... 

Trolls aren't real.
They're mythological creatures that don't actually exist in nature.

Are you next going to argue why Vampires and Werewolves can't exist in accordance with the rules of science and evolution?

Come on man. 

This was a fantasy sci-fi film, not a real documentary.
Please tell me they didn't fool you into thinking it was.

reply

@ B-J-C

Trolls die as soon as they're exposed to sunlight. Why didn't such a severe evolutionary drawback eliminate the species long ago?
Shucks, nobody took your dissertation seriously, so here you go:

There are many [millions?] species which have that characteristic. Like say, humans can't be in sunlight for long or they'll die. Then there's a particular species of salamander which has lived in an isolated underground habitat for around 100 million years--it's lost all skin pigmentation, eyesight capability etc.

Given their size, I imagine they might have difficulty always finding a cave to hide in that will fit them
You need to see Lord of the Rings--lots of massive caves and passages down there.

reply