MovieChat Forums > Trouble with the Curve (2012) Discussion > Amy Adams 'finds' ace pitcher outside se...

Amy Adams 'finds' ace pitcher outside seedy motel?


In the final throes of the movie - about to end without any cohesion - Amy Adams "hears" a curve ball being rocketed by an unknown pitcher who just happens to be throwing rockets to some kid outside of a seedy motel in the middle of North Carolina. She calls the old scout to ensure an audience at Braves field. He will pitch to the new STAR pick by the guy who pushed Amy Adams' father's opinion - Clint Easteood - out. Of course, the unknown Ace tosses a dozen pitches and the STAR can't hit one, proving Easteood correct. So 95% of the movie goes by, and this final 15 minutes wraps it up. It's the definition of INCREDULOUS.

reply


Not all movies are supposed to be the next Citizen Kane.


He's taking the knife out of the Cheese!
Do you think he wants some cheese?


reply

c'mon. this isn't even bubba kane.



Season's Greetings!

reply

Dear OP,

Possibly this might help:

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief

Next time, maybe get some popcorn and a beverage of your choice, kick back, and enjoy being entertained for a couple of hours by a collaborative creative endeavor that you didn't write.

Or, you could check out CSPAN...

Cheers!

reply

I found it hard to believe that this big, hulking prospect with a huge fastball and an even better curve could be caught by both his 10 year old brother and Amy Adams.

reply

dude...those huge fastball and curves are still thrown by a human. What's so great about them? Don't forget that his younger brother trains with him. And amy adams' character grew up playing baseball (as seen in one of the scene with her dad after the match). So what is the problem with catching a curve ball or two by both of them?

Jeez...if you are going to be an anal nitpicker in every little details in a movie, you might as well go watch national geographic channel.

And the part about finding an ace pitcher out of nowhere. Well, this is unlikely but doesn't mean it can't happen. There are many undiscovered talents in this world. Some people just didn't get the right chance or right moment to show what they are capable of. What's so hard to believe in that? They needed someone to throw a curve ball and the writer decided to add this "nobody" into the last scene to create something extra in the plot. He could have just used a star pitcher from the Braves team to show it but that would boring and predictable, isn't it? And he didn't want to bring in captain america as he was busy with the winter soldier. So he added this guy since he already shown him throwing peanut in earlier scene as a hint. Like I said again, it's a movie and it's meant to be an entertainment with limited context. A 1.5 hour movie does not have time to explain about every single little things for the audience.

reply

...those huge fastball and curves are still thrown by a human.


An extremely gifted human who has honed his skills day after day, week after week, month after month and year after year. All the while increasing in size, muscularity, knowledge and technique. A multitude of incremental improvements that deliver him far, far beyond the average human being in ability.

Major Leaguers are the cream of the cream of the cream of the crop. I hold then in reverence. Maybe you don't. Maybe you played and played well. I quit at age 14 being small and having yet to reach puberty, when I got burned in several ways going up against guys bigger to begin with and bigger still after their growth spurts.

reply

not sure why this is so incredible, scouts find players in weird places sometimes.

reply

As I remember, the ‘star’ prospect was really talented at swaggering in front of everyone else and diminishing their expectations; there was a hint of passive/situational prejudice in the plot; also, the pitcher’s mom was wisely insisting on “schoolwork first”. So the pitcher went unnoticed. He wasn’t playing on the team.

I also felt it wasn’t that much of a stretch.

reply

Title IX celebrates its 42nd birthday this summer.

My 5'6" daughter caught her brother (two years older than she and 6'2") for years as he developed. He was scouted by MLB until he threw his arm out in college; he was 54-20 lifetime and threw a slider, a curve and a 88-90 mph fastball. She went on to be a fastpitch softball catcher and was in the top 25 nationally in five categories as a senior (including #2 in slugging and #4 in HR's), and played for a national amateur championship team and a pro team. Her brother quit baseball after college and turned himself into a top amateur golfer (handicap below 6) and an award-winning wholesale golf salesman. Her favorite memorabilia is is an old "Foxtrot" cartoon with the tagline "Please don't kill me" is not a catcher's sign." "Well, it ought to be." She was elected to her college athletic hall of fame on her second year of eligibility; some of her records in college still stand; she's now 36, with two masters' degrees and two kids ages 6 & 4.

Sports and performance psychology apply to the rest of us too.

This film "Trouble With The Curve" is more about human connection than it is about a game of baseball.

Those two kids can both recite the full dialogue for the entire film "Field of Dreams" when it shows.

It's all about belief in self and excellence.


If You Want to Achieve Excellence...
You must have total intention to create it here and now.
Total intention is the powerful combination of desire, belief and acceptance.
You must not only desire it, but you must believe that you are capable of bringing it about.
And you must be willing to accept the positives and the responsibilities that will come when it arrives, as well as the responsibilities when it does not.



Archibald "Moonlight" Graham wrote the seminal research on juvenile hypertension: “Blood Pressures in Children Between the Ages of Five and Sixteen Years”, American Journal of Diseases of Children, volume 69, no. 4:203-207; primary author, A. W. Graham, M.D. (University of Maryland, 1905) ( Bats: Left, Throws: Right ).



One’s true capacity for moving,

or being moved, can be achieved

only when one’s commitment to others

is in fact connected to and derived from

his primary commitment to himself.

When we find this kind of alignment of purpose,

there is a harmony of motivation

that can provide the fuel and clarity

to overcome great obstacles

in the pursuit of great challenge.


from The Inner Game of Work,
by W. Timothy Gallwey




Mystery MLB Team Moves To Supercomputing For Their Moneyball Analysis

Posted by timothy on Saturday April 05, 2014 @06:08AM

from the stats-nerds-with-bats dept.

An anonymous reader writes

“A mystery [Major League Baseball] team has made a sizable investment in Cray’s latest effort at bringing graph analytics at extreme scale to bat. Nicole Hemsoth writes that what the team is looking for is a “hypothesis machine” that will allow them to integrate multiple, deep data wells and pose several questions against the same data. They are looking for platforms that allow users to look at facets of a given dataset, adding new cuts to see how certain conditions affect the reflection of a hypothesized reality.”


reply

Cool story bro

reply

i agree 100%. this isnt just some unknown prospect, this is the next Sandy Koufax who can only find work as a peanut vendor at a local high school baseball field.

reply

A kid who has to help his mom at the motel and doesn't have time to actually be on a team. Seems pretty reasonable to me.

reply

absolutely freakin stupid, it would be like a guy walking off the street and getting to bat against clayton kershaw and jacking a homerun.

reply

Kinda my thinking too.

There were a lot good actors in this, but the story was very predictable and unbelievable with some very unreal and stagey scenes that no one could see happening in real life.

http://www.oztvreviews.com/

reply

It doesn't matter. I still enjoyed this movie enough to watch it more than once even
though there's a few things that aren't realistic.

reply

That's the theme...you can find talent in the unlikeliest of places. Those in charge of hiring the best talent continue to use the same formula - going to the same places and using 'statistics' to determine who will be a success. The problem is as Amy's character said 'statistics aren't going to tell you if a kid is home sick' (paraphrasing) or going to perform well long term. It can't measure the size of someone's heart and ambition. Furthermore, the kid who grew up in the impoverished situation played the game better. He played and enjoyed the purity of the sport. If you noticed, the kid wasn't jaded by fortune or fame. He came out to play and that's it. He treated the recruiter with respect. On the other hand, the kid who was supposed to perform well based upon stats did miserably. He was motivated by money and stardom and made it clear baseball was the last thing on his mine - he was more interested in wine, women and having a good time - and not in that order!

reply

Geez Louise -- you guys get worked up OVER AN OPINION? Ok next time YOU OPINE and I'll criticize YOUR OPINIONS! At least I offered one -- . It only takes one ignorant human being to ruin this message board for all of us.

reply