MovieChat Forums > Jane Got a Gun (2016) Discussion > Only Good N. Portman is Star Wars N. Por...

Only Good N. Portman is Star Wars N. Portman


She can pretend she's a really diverse actress as much as she wants, make ten more westerns and win twenty more Oscars.

She'll always be N. Portman from Star Wars, no matter how hard she tries and no matter how much she claims that Star Wars almost ruined her career.

If she wants to show diversity of her acting abilities, she should do porn.

reply

[deleted]

Actually she had a small role in Heat as Al Pachinos step daughter. But I support the porn idea

reply

If she wants to show diversity of her acting abilities, she should do porn.

She played a Stripper in Closer (2004), is that close enough?

reply

Not hardcore enough. I saw that movie and she doesn't even look good in it.

reply

You are such an idiot, spending so much time (here and on other boards) spouting off "why" you think actors do various things and mostly criticizing them. Just don't go see their movies if they upset you so much. Get a life, find something you enjoy instead of dwelling on all the things you think are wrong.

..*.. TxMike ..*..

reply

You must be a die-hard fan of hers.

LOL.

That I wouldn't be.

reply

She's OK, but I am not a big fan, she's just one of many competent actresses. But I am a big "anti-fan" of all the idiots, you being one of them, who get their kicks out of going to a discussion board just to throw insults, no matter who the actor or actress is. It is petty and juvenile.

** TxMike **

PS - For anyone else wondering, 'gorkee' edited his original post and took out the snide remarks and unfair criticisms. At least he knows he was wrong.

reply

I still think anything she did and does after Star Wars reeks of some kind of anti-Amidala desperation. Jackie Kennedy or western Jane are obviously such "complex and deep" nothing-to-do-with-Star Wars roles.

To "really prove" that she can act in something else besides a G. Lucas flick.

So that she's a "talented", "nuanced" and "versatile" actress. A diva who has a "range". Star Wars was the highlight of her career. It's all south from there. If she wants to prove her versatility, it would be better if she did some porn, a threesome with Master Yoda and Ewan McGregor. Imagine Darth Vader "hop in and out": "Oh, I love you, Ani, I love foursome so much ...!"

And then, sadly, she dies.

Honestly, also before SW she wasn't much of an actress.

Take her flick Leon: The Professional where she was cast as Mathilda.

Either her or Jean Reno, although both ghastly overrated, are completely forgettable. Mathilda's love relationship with Leon in that movie is, mildly put, sick. It's a good thing at least Leon ends up dead before it becomes disturbing. Mathilda should be dead too. To have a name so dumb and stay alive until the end credits?

Seriously, now that's a plot error of galactic proportions, beyond any plausibility.

I think that movie, for instance, should be titled after Steinfeld, the legendary and best rogue cop on screen like ever, played by Gary Oldman.

He stole that show (F'ck you, Jean Reno!), remains IMHO only true star of that otherwise dumb film and deserves an Oscar solely for his onscreen presence. But he will never get one for that or anything else he does.

Mediocre actors like Natalie Portman - they get one by the time they're 35. Let's leave aside the fact that Black Swan is an insult to intelligence and a morbid waste of time or money. It's not a movie, but obviously another post-Amidala tragedy.

Thank you, Academy.

reply

Natalie Portman was well known, before the Star Wars films, and I'm sure that fact, is the reason why she was cast in the first place. I personally don't believe, that Star Wars did anything for her career in a positive way. She has received a lot of criticism over the years, for her performance in those films, but no one gives a good performance, they are all totally forgettable. When you have good actors and actresses with talent, and a not so good director, the result are films like Star Wars, and they were a big disappointment for me. George Lucas is an exceptional filmmaker, but I would have to disagree with anyone, that says he is a good director

Most everyone agrees that Natalie's role as Mathilda, is her most noted accomplishment in film, despite her Oscar win for Black Swan, (myself included). I definitey disagree with your OP!!!

reply

The fact you can't get over Star Wars makes me sad for you. In Portman's career Star Wars is a blip.

reply

Almost anyone who is in Star Wars will always be thought of as that role, maybe the exception being Harrison, solely because of Dr Jones too..

Portman is just so dam pretty, I could watch her do do almost anything... especially a nice porno!!! Until then.... here's the name of a porn Star look alike...

Tori Black........ Enjoy!

reply

I thought she was good in The Professional with Leon...

reply