MovieChat Forums > Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 (2012) Discussion > Great except for the scene with the mayo...

Great except for the scene with the mayor. (spoiler)


I really enjoyed this movie even though I'm not aware of which exact comic is based on. The thing I felt was really strange was the scene with the mayor going into prison cell alone with a known killer. Was that scene based on something else maybe from the original comic book that I might not be aware of?

reply

This is exactly how it plays out in the comic. The mayor is extremely naive and incompetent. He won't do anything without consulting polls, and seems paralyzed by indecision at times. He really doesn't have a clue what the Mutant leader is capable of, and falsely believes he can negotiate a truce with him. The Mutant leader kills him for fun (essentially) and knows there will be no consequences because his gang will break him out sooner or later.

reply

Thanks for explaining it. Having not read the original comic that's derived from this universe sounds like this is much darker than the previous Batman animation I've seen. Sounds like they really pegged a parody of an incompetent politician in this.

reply

Frank Miller wrote and drew the graphic novel The Dark Knight Returns in the mid-1980s. It was originally serialized in four parts, then collected in graphic novel form.

"Loyalty. Honor. A willing heart. I can ask no more than that." - Thorin Oakenshield

reply

That makes sense it was a graphic novel thanks for explaining that. This treatment comes across a little more realistic within the Batman universe.

reply

Actually the scene is a bit different in the comic. In the comic you see it from the Mutant Leader's perspective, and just see the shocked faces of Gordon and the police officers.

They don't show the blood and body like in the animated movie, they let you imagine what the Mutant Leader did. That made it much creepier.

I would have preferred if they did it the same way.

reply

well i dnt think they should have such killin in such kid movie? cos it cud make kids go kill other peeps which we NOT want......

reply

Who told you this was a kid's movie?

Will someone get Greengrass a f*#king steadicam?!

reply

ahahahaha cos it BATMAN dnt u know that is kid comix???? ahahahaha y wud u not know all'about superfends and such stuff ahahahaa dnt u know anythn at all cos thats wut u must lrn pls!!!!

reply

*gives georgegliddy a blank stare*
retard

reply

y'u say such????? r u intrnet bull on me!!!!

reply

Dude. Go away. Or learn to type. Your stupidity is a plague on this board.

reply

ok well u r just mean so y shoud i care any such wut U say? bad peeps go away!!!!!!!

reply

No, Batman is not a kids comic. Something like "Peanuts" is a kids comic. They have adaptations of Batman that are kid friendly like the Adam West Batman or Batman the animated series, but not the comics and not all of the movies. This is one of the ones that is not.

reply

Hahah that scene was one of my favorites. I mean, the mayor probably didn't really deserve it, but you know, whatever. Still cool.

-------------------------------------


(-_-)

reply

pls do NOT lauf on peeps get killed.....4 it is such sad on ur society........

reply

Let´s skip Georgliddy´s comments. His thoughts on cartoons are stereotyped and he does not know how to type. Get ready to press ignore button.

I love classic monsters.

reply

Did he eat the mayor or something? I mean it looked like he ripped his neck apart with his teeth or something.

reply

it looked like he ripped his neck apart with his teeth or something. - magemaximus


Exactly. The Mutant leader tore the mayor's throat out with his filed teeth. The book spells this out.

reply

well u cud atk on me all u wud want but if ur so ful of h8 u cud go to jail and that wud b BAD.... so pls just d'nt h8 spx on peeps cos that is ilegal!!!!!!

reply

I think that it was a good scene. It showed that you have to dot your I's and cross your T's, and not leave anything up to chance and trust.

reply

well sir or mam i cnt figure out wut ur talking about across all such internet u keep saying dum dum stuf not make ANY sense????????

reply

No, don't ignore him. Because his posts are *beep* hilarious!

reply

You're right. That was dumb of me. Comedy gold.

I love classic monsters.

reply