Are you telling me.....? SPOILER ALERT


SPOILER ALERT

Enjoying this movie so far, but had to stop at a complete absurdity of logic:

Are you telling me that a short fat mayor would a be willing to go into a cell with a mass murderer psychopath. alone..oh..also in the dark..oh also while said huge psychopath is only in some little handcuff. This is absurd F(&Y@W)*YTW@??!!

I don't care if he said I'm going in alone. NOBODY ON EARTH WOULD DO THIS and this seriously is annoying when someone in a movie does something that nobody would do.

Someone below said basically it's a movie about a man in a batsuit so anything can happen. Buffoonery.

Just because someone is in a bat costume doesn't mean that anything can happen. If bananas started to shoot out of everyone's butt in the movie from beginning to end would you say..."oh it's a movie about a bat so anything can happen?"

regardless of if someone is in a batsuit or a superman suit, it establishes itself in the real world and as such noone would logically enter a cell with in the dark, in close quarters, inches away, with a giant man, who is a mass murderer.

No one on earth would be that stupid, nor would a police commissioner allow it, regardless of what he says. you mean he could talk to him behind bars, behind a glass.....to talk with this guy he had to sit on his lap? really?

reply

arrogance can get a man killed, and in this cartoon/comic it did

reply

Yes, that is the only illogical thing in a movie about a man in a bat costume ... that scene totally pulled me out of the realism of this documentary.

reply

sadly you don't know the difference between what works in this reality of this comic book based movie. Just because someone is in a bat costume doesn't mean that anything can happen. If bananas started to shoot out of everyone's butt in the movie from beginning to end would you say..."oh it's a movie about a bat so anything can happen?"

regardless of if someone is in a batsuit or a superman suit, it establishes itself in the real world and as such noone would logically enter a cell with in the dark, in close quarters, inches away, with a giant man, who is a mass murderer.

No one on earth would be that stupid, nor would a police commissioner allow it, regardless of what he says. you mean he could talk to him behind bars, behind a glass.....to talk with this guy he had to sit on his lap? really?

reply

Go away.

reply

Just to recap mope. I was here first. Hence, you know, why you responded. And wrongly.

reply

I just don't see the point in having a flame war over the "realism" of a superhero cartoon.

reply

The mayor is a cowardly politician who's afraid to make a decision. He decided that this was his opportunity to show real leadership.

reply

yes, i know that, but nobody is that stupid to walk into a dark cell with a mass murderer. alone. And nobody, no law enforcement officer in his right mind would allow it.

reply

Well, it was more to make him popular with the voters than an act of leadership.

reply

It's more unbelievable that a girl who couldn't even climb down a storm drain and had trouble pulling herself over a railing is suddenly sprinting on rooftops and doing flips in the air.

reply

I think it was different in the comics. In the comics, you just see the Mayor enter the room and you don't see the Mutant Leader, and then you just see Gordon's shocked face and the narration.

They never showed it in the graphic novel, and they certainly didn't close the door on him like they did in the animated movie.

reply