MovieChat Forums > Alien: Covenant (2017) Discussion > Why do they speed everything up?

Why do they speed everything up?


Xenomorphs are now born and fully grown in a matter of minutes?

This processus took days in the original movies.

reply

DING DING DING *WINNER*

reply

I guess we're supposed to assume that David later slowed down the incubation period for some reason. But the real reason is movies are dumb now and people want action!

reply

It was just as "dumb" in 1979. The xeno grew from chestburster to full-size in like an hour of the movie universe's time (and just minutes of screen time).

This is reminding me of Prometheus, a movie that got slammed and bashed for stuff that Alien did as well, and stuff that was actually more "dumb" in Alien. I won't even get into Aliens.

Plenty of old classics have deep flaws and/or nitpicky things that are simply overlooked because nitpicking for criticism just wasn't as popular. I consider nitpicking to be a fun mental exercise, it doesn't apply to my enjoyment of a movie unless the movie is striving for real-world logic and fails in very large ways that affect the plot (and of course those kinds of flaws aren't actually nitpicks, they are logic fails, plot holes, character fails, etc).

These days nitpicking is often used as some kind of objective backing to a negative opinion, which is asinine.

reply

^^^THIS^^^ALL^^^OF^^^THIS^^^

reply

^A movie-chat-er after my own heart! Thanks for your endorsement

reply

Not a problem...I've read several posts of yours and they are never Melon headed...just keen observations and rational opinions. if my endorsement means anything, you surely have itπŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘

reply

Get a room, you two!

reply

Oh not necessary...I'm the kinda guy that can give compliments out in the openπŸ˜‰

reply

Well we had a room to ourselves until you barged in! I guess you like to watch >_>

reply

You are remembering incorrectly. In Alien, it took very little time.

https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/2l20nu/how_does_the_xenomorph_in_alien_1979_grow_so_big/

reply

This one has stumped my friend and I for over 35 years! Best we came up with was the lil booger must have feasted on Kane's innards and some how stored the nutrients to later be synthesized into a super nutrient by use of its silicone cell regeneration. Our speculation pretty much ended there as we had no fucking idea what silicone cells were nor the Internet to research. Now much older I know why...the movie would have sucked if not for the accelerated growth process...plain and simple LOL!

reply

the movie would have sucked if not for the accelerated growth process

Definitely agreed... Plus they probably would have found the chestburster and killed it pretty easily. Or found Jonesy the cat chewing on it!

reply

Ridley Scott.

reply

The first one made a bit of sense, given they had to walk 8 km and back through difficult terrain, that would have taken hours. But from the second one on...

reply

"Alien" had a great cast, great creature effects (Carlo Rambaldi), great visual effects (Brian Johnson and Nick Allder of "Space: 1999" and "Empire Strikes Back"), and a great film score (Jerry Goldsmith). When you have that, you don't tend to worry about inconsistencies, plot holes, etc. in the story.

With something like "Covenant," you don't have any of what "Alien" did, so its story problems stare you straight in the face.

reply