MovieChat Forums > Bird Box (2018) Discussion > Supernatural or Inter-dimensional?

Supernatural or Inter-dimensional?


SPOILER ALERT! If you haven't watched "Bird Box" yet, don't read until you've seen it.

Now that we've got that out of the way, the creatures had to have been either supernatural or inter-dimensional. As mentioned by a previous poster, the movie has elements of "A Quiet Place" and "The Mist." At the same time, the movie is completely different in that it takes on the supernatural aspects of an apocalyptic scenario when Charlie address the folklore of various religions and when Gary lays out the pictures of demonic looking beings on the table. These are subtle hints as to the nature of the creatures.

If they are demons (supernatural beings), then I find it interesting that no one ever stops to have a group discussion about what (if any) religious defenses they might try to use against them. They obviously want to do harm to the living and the ways people kill themselves is usually ghastly. This conveys a nature of malice.

If they are inter-dimensional (time/space beings), they could be creatures that feed off the energy of extreme fear/psychosis/euphoria and deplete that energy quickly by killing off their hosts. This would make them parasitic in nature. However there's a wrinkle with that explanation and that's the people the creatures keep alive to do their bidding, such as Gary and the roving killers that Tom puts down at the house. The creatures can obviously not kill people they attack all the time, so that shows a more deliberate intelligence. In nature, some varieties of parasites will keep a host alive for a while, if it's beneficial to them. This conveys that perhaps the creatures aren't so much evil as they are opportunists.

Some hints of answers in the movie but very little to go on. Guesswork here.

Other thoughts?


reply

I have a question -- what were some of the worst fears of the victims? Can you give me 3 or 4? I will explain why I'm asking after I hear your answer.

Thanks!

reply

You never really know. Her sister says "Oh my God, what is that?!?" when they are fleeing the hospital. The wife at the house mutters the words "Mom?" before she seats herself in a burning car, so that's not necessarily a moment of fear. I also mentioned inducing psychosis/euphoria over their victims, so it may not be just using fear as a stimulant. It could just be some sort of overpowering emotion or vision.

My thoughts above are speculation at best and guesses at worst.

reply

Maybe I have it wrong. Somewhere I got the idea that they were seeing their worst fear. Does it say that somewhere or did I make that up?

Oh, I found it! Someone in the trailer says it takes on the form of your worst fears.

reply

It really doesn't seem to be fears. It seems to be that it becomes kind of a mocking Jay (if you've seen the hunger games) of your deceased or longed-for loved ones. It disorients you or begs you until you look at it and then it drives you mad if you aren't already mentally ill. I'm not sure where the fears thing comes from

reply

The mockingjay thing actually seems to be more distressing. I once read a movie review, can't remember which movie, but it was one in which the monster took on the form of your greatest fear. The reviewer made a case that people's greatest fears aren't really a giant spider or a room full of snakes or anything like that. Our greatest fears are fear of abandonment, loss of love, becoming disabled, things like that. Things can scare us but our true fears are about freedom and relationship. (I'm sure there was more in the review but I can't find it.) Even though a room full of snakes would horrify me, it would be much worse to see my child suffering in some terrible way.

reply

That was Charlie, when he was explaining spirits of different religious folklore.

reply

Let's not forget, the entity(ies) cause a brain and/or body chemistry change in humans, their eyes change color.

Personally, I think the entity(ies) just employ a form of psycho mind control. You see the most important person of your life forcing you to suicide. You don't have a choice, they say do it, you say ok.

reply

It’s Cthulhu and his star spawn. Look him up.

reply