Tar?


Perhaps I yawned and missed something but I didnt understand the whole tar scene. How did it get in her hair? From laying on the roof and she inexplicably hadnt noticed before she went to bed? Had the grandmother snuck in and put it in her hair and inexplicably not woken her up? The grandmother demands Chris cut her hair for being insolent. He refuses. She withholds food for days then finally gives in. And THEN she gets tar in her hair and he cuts it? And the grandmother never says word one about it after, so theres no acknowledgement that she got her way IF it was her doing or even any snide satisfaction about it at all. It just disappears as a plot point from the movie entirely at that point and Shipka just continues the movie as short haired Cathy and everyone is fine with that. The whole thing was perplexing and random to me. Why was this scene even there? Was this the directors awful attempt to make Cathy look different from her mother so the audience could understand the growing difference between them (not a reflection of her mother). If so then he would have been better off having her cut her own hair out of anger or bitterness or something which, although cliched (White Oleander anyone?), would get the point across. And not just have this random scene where theres no reason for the hair cutting and nothing comes of it anyway.

---
Using words to describe art is like using a screw driver to cut roast beef.

reply

In the book the grandmother puts the tar in Cathy's hair because she knows how much Cathy loves her hair and sees it as she is being vain. In the book he dosent cut off all of her hair just enough so when its wrapped up it looks like it was cut off.

reply

The book suggests that Grandmother had injected her with a tranquilizer to keep her asleep as she put the tar in her hair. Cathy notices a prick on her arm.

reply

I thought she put it in the food so all th ekids would sleep through The Grandmother being in the attic in the Middle of the night.

Slainte 🇮🇪 I am who I am your approval isnt needed or required.




reply

In the book, Cathy wakes up to find the tar in her hair one morning. There's also a needle mark on her arm, so I assume she was given some sort of sedative so she wouldn't wake up.




"It's better to be hated for who you are than be loved for who you aren't."

reply

so its clear in the book? why didnt they do that in the movie? does the grandmother refer to it after the fact in the book at all? does she at least smile knowingly or smirk or make a loaded statement or ANYTHING? or does she act completely oblivious like she does in the movie where it just disappears as a plot point?

---
Using words to describe art is like using a screw driver to cut roast beef.

reply

Well I never said the movie was perfect.




"It's better to be hated for who you are than be loved for who you aren't."

reply

oh I wasnt criticizing your comment. Thanks for addressing my question. I was just wondering the difference between how it comes off in the book and in the movie. if you havent read the book, this scene comes off as a huge WTF moment.

---
Using words to describe art is like using a screw driver to cut roast beef.

reply

It was rather WTF even if you have read the book. It's a bit silly in the book, too, IMO. I recall my impression was that the Grandmother sedated then moved Cathy to another room to put the tar on, otherwise it would have rather messed up her pillow. And there was a good deal more tar involved, like masses of the stuff binding up all her hair and set hard, not just a bit of gooey stuff that Chris could have washed out (which is what it looked like in the movie).

Oh, and in the book he pees in the bathwater and tells her to as well, in the hope that ammonia will get the tar out. Yep, that happens.

reply