MovieChat Forums > Circle (2015) Discussion > How did no one notice this about the sol...

How did no one notice this about the soldier ?


The soldier says he's been in Afghanistan for the last 2 years and JUST got back. Right after, he says he has a 7 month-old waiting for him at home. Why was no one at least mentioning the clear discrepancy there ?

The obvious explanation is that he got cheated on while he was gone. Could be that he was blatantly lying to get sympathy. But really, NO ONE is mentioning this at all ? That's the weirdest thing about this movie for me.

reply

Soldiers get leave to go home...

reply

He stated in the movie he was gone for two years...

There are maybe five beings I hope I never have to fight and J'onn Jonzz is one of them. - Superman

reply

As prior military I was deployed for a year on a couple occasions. I got leave halfway through each time. I still say I was deployed or gone for a year.

This is the same thing.

reply

Makes sense then. Probably could have been better explained in the movie for most people watching probably aren't military. But to be fair, the movie wasn't the smartest thing ever made lol

There are maybe five beings I hope I never have to fight and J'onn Jonzz is one of them. - Superman

reply

Exactly. Usually two weeks of R&R, at least in my personal experience. This is listed as a goof too and definitely isn't necessarily right.

reply

Umm you don't know much about Soldiers do you? They get to go home sometimes on leave....

reply

And you both missed in the movie and in the OP that he said he was gone for two years. I assumed he didn't mean two years exactly, just that it was a couple years as a general term, which was actually 16 months. It probably felt longer. Just a mistake though I suppose.

There are maybe five beings I hope I never have to fight and J'onn Jonzz is one of them. - Superman

reply

[deleted]

He's a *beep* Marine. Non-reg hair cut and gunny rolls on a Sgt, but still a Marine. Semper Fi.

reply

He was trying to play the cuckold card for sympathy, but no one got it.lol

reply

You mean nobody in the movie or nobody including viewers? It is in the goofs section so someone noticed it. As for why the other characters didn't, I'm not sure.







--------------------------------
I did sixty in five minutes once...

reply

Maybe he left a turkey baster in the freezer.

reply