MovieChat Forums > The Astronaut Wives Club (2015) Discussion > Was Grissom to blame? ...... fact check

Was Grissom to blame? ...... fact check


http://zap2it.com/2015/08/astronaut-wives-club-nasa-gus-grissom-fire/



Grands...Glad to see you come and glad to see you go

reply

Please don't post links to outside sources unless you have the background to be able to evaluate their sources. If the article isn't quoting a space historian of the stature of Jim Oberg or Andrew Chaikin, regard it as questionable. Space.com has a mixed record of factual accuracy. When they reprint stuff from reputable sources, fine, but too often they run lunatic fringe stuff just to draw eyeballs. Don't feed the trolls.

Besides, you should have known from watching the last episode that the writer of that article already had his/her facts wrong. What's shown in the episode is a representative from North American Aviation hinting that Gus was to blame, not anyone from NASA. Plus anyone who watched should have immediately known from common sense that it was a bogus cover-up accusation. If there had been wires hanging down where Gus could have kicked them, causing a fatal short, that would have been NAA's fault anyway. IIRC, the location of the fatal arc source was eventually traced to up behind the instrument panel where none of the astronauts could have contacted the wiring.

It's unfortunate but sadly correct that the writers of the last episode included the rumor that Gus might have caused the fire, because that did happen. In the end, Gus was exonerated (again!) and Betty won a settlement in her lawsuit against NAA.

reply

wab-3, thank you for a factual and well thought out response. I would trust zap2it website to give a factual account of the writers last meal let alone something about NASA.

reply

Particularly since they referred to the Apollo 1 capsule as a "shuttle". Five freaking times.

reply

wab-3
This is not a documentary. Was Gus Grissom shot into space? Fact Did three men die? Fact Did they try to blame Gus Grissom? Rumor Was there something wrong with the capsule? Fact Was Pat White distraught. Fact She committed suicide later in life. Was the Apollo 1 investigated? Fact

Grands...Glad to see you come and glad to see you go

reply

You're hardly the one who should be claiming factual accuracy when you cited an article that was factually wrong on critical details. NASA did not try to blame Gus for the fire.

reply

The review board clearly showed the crew was not at fault. All three crew members had noted issues for several weeks leading up to the tragedy. Grissom had complained that something smelled "off" several times, and that it was particularly noticeable as they entered the capsule that day.

NAA tried to scapegoat Gus Grissom because they thought they could. It failed miserably, thank God, and rightfully so.

reply

Additionally, NAA was pissed at Gus for his "off the record" comment to Florida Today during the Gemini flights.

When he was asked how it felt to be in the air right before launch, Gus asked the reporter how HE would feel being up in the air "knowing each and every damn piece of this thing was made by the lowest bidder?"

reply

Well, not quite. NAA didn't build the Gemini capsule, McDonnell-Douglas did. But Gus was known to be making similar bitches about NAA during the lead-up to the fire.

reply

Actually, just McDonnell Aircraft. They did not merge with Douglass Aircraft until 1967.

reply