Looks like The Right Stuff


From what I have seen, this looks like a TV retelling of The Right Stuff..the author must have either seen the movie or read the book and decided to put their spin on it.

reply

Well, they're both obviously focused on the Mercury program, at least so far. I don't know a lot about the book the show is based on, but I think it's a fairly safe bet the author's research included reading The Right Stuff, among a huge volume of other things. I think there are at least a hundred books that cover the Mercury program, either specifically or as part of work covering the space program or the period more broadly. I believe each of the original seven astronauts except Grissom has written at least one book (or collaborated with a ghost writer, anyway). EDIT: Make that all seven: Grissom authored a book ("Gemini") too.

It's not exactly like the events occurred in obscurity and were discovered by Tom Wolfe: in some sense, you might say the "first version" of the story of that phase of the space program was published in real time in the form of news stories, magazine feature pieces, NASA reports and overnight books.

I don't think it's particularly a "retelling" of The Right Stuff, except to the extent that, given any pair of works that are based on the same historical events, the second one to appear is a "retelling" of the first. I suppose one might describe Saving Private Ryan as a retelling of The Longest Day.

There are a lot of differences between the two. The Right Stuff focused heavily on how the astronauts' ethos derived from that of military test pilots. The book and - more so - the movie, were focused on creating a sort of mythology around the astronauts. The TV show seems to be going the opposite direction. The Right Stuff ended with the last Mercury mission, while this TV show apparently will go further - through Gemini and at least up to Apollo.

reply

I sure hope, though, that people who only saw the movie realize that The Right Stuff as a book was about three times as thick. Likewise with this show.

Although what I'm mostly hoping is that the 75% of the US that thinks Armstrong faked it will change their minds.

reply

...Or it's just an adaptation of Lily Koppel's non-fiction book of the same name

When the stars are the only things we share
Will you be there?


-Benjamin Francis Leftwich

reply

Actually, there had been talk for years--including by the Mercury 7 astronauts themselves--that "someone" should write a book about the wives' experiences. Somebody finally did, and thus we have the eponymous book based on the real Astronaut Wives Club, on which this series is based. The book covers the Gemini and Apollo wives as well, so presumably we'll get their stories if the series is renewed for more seasons.

reply

I only know that after I watch each episode, I'm tempted to watch The Right Stuff again.
"Well my name is Jim, but most people call me.....Jim."

reply

The Right Stuff was told from Gordo's point of view. In this version, Gordo is an ass.

reply

Actually, Gordo is portrayed as much bigger of an ass in the film version of The Right Stuff...which wasn't told from his perspective, either.

reply

Did you watch the movie?

Gordon Cooper: Yeah, but uh, nurse, how am I supposed to uh...
Nurse Murch: The best results seem to be obtained through fantasization, accompanied by masturbation, followed by ejaculation.
Gordon Cooper: Well, that sounds easy enough.

Gordon Cooper: You know something, Gus? I got me a new house, new furniture. Got me $25,000 a year on a magazine contract. Got me a Corvette. Got free lunch from one end of America to the other - and I ain't even been up there yet.
Gus Grissom: Yeah, I noticed that.
Gordon Cooper: Oh, you noticed that, did you? Well I guess they're just saving the best for last.
Gus Grissom: Yeah, I guess so, Hot Dog. Just be sure you don't screw the pooch.


And who gets the last scene, in monologue? GORDO.

The Mercury program was over.

Four years later,
Astronaut Gus Grissom was killed...

along with Astronauts White and Chaffee...

when fire swept through
their Apollo capsule.

But on that glorious day in May, 1963...

Gordo Cooper went higher, farther...

and faster than any other American.

Twenty-two complete orbits
around the world.

He was the last American
ever to go into space alone.

And for a brief moment...

Gordo Cooper became the greatest pilot
anyone had ever seen.

reply

Many times. Where is Gordo when John and Annie are discussing whether the other guys think he's a Dudley Doright? Where is he when Betty and Gus are arguing why the hatch blew? When Al Shepard is suffering with the enema bag? Etc., etc. Gordo gets his share of the limelight as comic relief, but he's just one of the 4 (Alan, Gus, Gordo and John) who the film focuses on primarily.

reply

TRS focused on the Air Force guys. Shepard and Glenn had a lot of time, but Carpenter and Schirra were practically extras.

I'm glad to see that TAWC seems to focus on all seven of them, although when they actually focus on the guys it does seem weighted toward Shepard and Cooper Wally is again getting the short end of the stick.

In FTETTM, Wally was the big focus of the third episode, but was presented as almost a bad guy.

Schirra was probably the best pilot of all of the Mercury guys. He had three very tough missions, and all were technically successful. He probably was too tough on Apollo 7, and certainly in orbit was difficult to work with from the ground.

reply

Well, Wally is due to get lots of airtime in the next episode, which will presumably focus on his flight.

I have never understood why TRS barely paid attention to Wally, making him out to be this quiet wallflower. At least he's getting his due in this series.

The FTETTM writers seemed to have drunk Chris Kraft's Kool-Aid with regard to Apollo 7. That was all about Kraft declaring himself fuehrer of flight ops, and Kraft's attempts at cowing the astronauts and flight controllers into following his dictats blindly. If it hadn't been for a junior flight controller piping up to say, "Try SCE to Aux" and Al Bean hitting that switch without requesting confirmation, Apollo 12 would have aborted during ascent. Kraft had dick to do with that miracle.

reply

Ah, you just brought up my main complaint from the last episode. Wally has already had his flight - they totally blew over it. Lots of discussion on before the flight, and then they go right to the Ball and the Cuban Missile Crisis.

reply

Yes, that struck me too. They blew over his flight so quickly on the series, it was kind of hard to tell whether it happened or not. There were a few lines at the beginning referring to it as coming up, then the gala, etc., then - in a scene that revolved around Jo's Junior League membership invitation - she mentioned that Wally orbited (past tense) the earth. I had to look up the dates to confirm that his mission did, in fact, occur before the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Obviously, they're not going into detail with each mission, as the series seems to run at least to 1968 (the RFK assassination has been teased) and perhaps to 1969 or later. There aren't enough episodes even to mention every flight, much less to introduce all the astronauts involved. But it was strange how that one happened in the middle of an episode without even a ten-second insert shot of liftoff or anything.

reply

Jesus, no wonder I missed the coverage of Wally's flight. I thought that Jo was referring to his upcoming flight in that scene. Oh, that's bad, real bad. Wally's "technically perfect" flight was a big deal because it made him one of the top candidates for Gemini flights and sort of sealed the deal on Carpenter's exile from future flights.

Seems to me they're bringing in the New Nine wives way too soon. Granted, the timing may be historically accurate but here's where I would have fudged with the exact timeline in order to get the most out of the stories of the Seven wives. I wonder if they're rushing because they think they won't be renewed for a second season.

reply