MovieChat Forums > Toni Erdmann (2016) Discussion > If the movie doesn't win Oscar you must ...

If the movie doesn't win Oscar you must protest


I feel they gonna give it to the Iranian film just because of the political events
If that happened you must protest
Cause we all know your film deserve it

reply

Have you even seen The Salesman? It's a fair question.


WARNING: I'M SEXY!

reply

Yes and Toni Erdman is better, Land of mine is better too
If they give it to the Salesman it will be for political reasons not anymore

reply

I somehow don't believe you did, because you referred to it as the "Iranian film" in your OP. Why not say "The Salesman"?

It's ok though, I'll watch both and make up my mind about them. I still really want to see Toni Erdmann but a lot of non-critics seem to think this movie is overlong and annoying, and mainly "not funny". I've heard very good things about The Salesman, but you know, I'm sure I won't be as blown away by it as I was A Separation, which was magnificent.

WARNING: I'M SEXY!

reply

If they had an Oscar for best cum pastry in film perhaps? Otherwise screw this film and all the other artsy fartsy bullsh!t out there.

This will be the only comment or reply you'll get. Like I give a sh!t about YOUR interwebz opinion.

reply

[deleted]

I said Iranian film cause they will give to the film because it's Iranian not because it's a good film I've seen it and I know Asghar Farhadi 's work and all the awards goes this year to Toni Erdman and it supposed to win unless they give it to Iran as a reply to Trump
Like Meryl nomination we all know she's overrated but they nominate her and neglect Amy Adams, Sally Field and Annette Benning just to tell Trump she's not overated

reply

So u don't believe me and u just haven't seen Toni Erdman yet and u takin ur opinion through critics!! What a funny story!
Look kid I don't care if u believe or not cause I'm here cause I watch them all, when u watch the 5 films Go and defend yours or discuss it stupid argument

reply

I saw "Toni Erdmann" twice and it deserves to win.

It's a surprisingly thoughtful film, very rich and without any conventional story or style.

It takes a lot of risks and they all pay off in the end.

reply